How to Pick a Good Deer Taxidermist

How to Pick a Good Deer Taxidermist

Taxidermists are like referees. When they do their job well, you hardly notice them. But when the job is done poorly, it commands attention in a bad way.

In many cases, exceptional taxidermy contains details that the average person won’t pick up on. I reached out to some taxidermists to ask what they look for when judging a peer’s work, and here’s what they said customers should be keen to.

Eye shape and placement is critical, and it’s often the first area someone’s own eyes go when looking at a mount (after antlers, of course).

“Incorrect eye shapes and sizes can make a deer look scared, mad, confused, surprised, etc.,” said Matt Gonsor, owner of Missouri Valley Taxidermy. “This is one of the most visible things on your mount that doesn’t come directly off of your animal. Taxidermists have to buy eyes from dealers, and you can usually tell who spends extra money on eyes and who doesn’t.”

The best eyes will look relaxed and have a blending of brown and black colors while still being bright. It’s also worth checking out tear ducts, which should have definition instead of being flat.

Ears should look crisp, without wrinkles or loose skin. While I don’t normally recommend touching another man’s taxidermy, fondling a deer’s ears is the best way to get an idea of quality work. When done incorrectly, the taxidermist often chooses the wrong size for the ear inserts.

“Ears should feel firm all the way to the tip,” said Josh Neuharth, owner of Western Wildlife Creations. “This can be one of the hardest things to nail for a taxidermist. Skinning out this portion of the deer and placing it on the mount is a delicate process, and one that’s regularly screwed up.”

Often at eye-level, the muzzle of a deer is critical to get right. The nose pad should be a shade of dark brown, dark gray, or light black with a slight gradient. It should have a naturally wet look but stop short of shining.

“A deer’s nose should never be charcoal black, even though that’s how a lot of taxidermists present them,” Gonsor said.

Customers should also look at the nostrils, which you shouldn’t be able to see all the way into. Ideally, the nostril cavity will extend deep into the deer’s muzzle and be a shade of gray, brown, or pink.

Next time you’re shopping around to get your trophy mounted, look for these three things on a taxidermist’s website or in their showroom to guarantee a job well done. It can be the difference between someone appreciating your antlers and wondering why you let an amateur handle your deer.


Phantom Saddle Kit
Save this product

If you are looking for a nimble and effective way to hunt deer this fall, the Phantom Saddle Kit is the ticket!

Mens Wick Short Sleeve Crew
Save this product
First Lite

Mark’s summer shirt of choice. It’s breathable, quick drying, and super comfortable.

Impact 1000 Rangefinder
Save this product
Vortex Optics

The Impact 1000 is all you need in a whitetail bowhunting rangefinder and nothing more.

Deadshot Boxed Combo Shooting Bag - Unfilled
Save this product

Make your groups more consistent when sighting in your rifle. Best $25 investment of the year.

Get the latest in your inbox
Subscribe to our newsletters to receive regular emails with hand-picked content, gear recommendations, and special deals.
Our picks for the week's best content and gear
For the whitetail obsessed, with Mark Kenyon
Redefining our connection to food, with Danielle Prewett
Your one-stop for everything waterfowl, with Sean Weaver
Get out on the water with the MeatEater Fishing crew
Technical hunting apparel
Purpose-built accessories for hunting and fishing
Quality elk, turkey, waterfowl, and deer calls
Save this article