00:00:00 Speaker 1: A duck hunter is driving to a lake in Florida's Panhandle. He's excited to try out a new spot. A cold front is in the forecast, and he's hopeful he'll get a few birds. But then, just a few hours later, he's gone. His boat remains by the shoreline, but his body has disappeared. His friends and family are left wondering if he crashed into an underwater tree, ran into a hungry alligator, or encountered something else. far more dangerous. That's next on Blood Trails, brought to you by Takovas. If you're a hunter who's married or in a serious relationship, you understand the push and pull between spending time with your significant other and spending time in the great outdoors. In December of 2000, Damon Jasper was feeling that tension when his buddy, Mike Williams, asked him to go duck hunting two weekends in a row. 00:01:04 Speaker 2: Probably the last time I talked to Mike was earlier in that week, and he was talking about going hunting again, and I was like, I can't do it, man. I gotta spend time with my girlfriend. I can't get up and go with you, and then I'll be worthless the rest of the day. 00:01:22 Speaker 1: Mike was married himself, but his wife, Denise, was apparently fine with her husband spending his December weekends in the duck boat. Damon didn't mention whether he was jealous of his friend as the next Saturday rolled around, but all envious thoughts fell by the wayside when he got a call from Denise. 00:01:40 Speaker 2: She said that she was upset. 00:01:42 Speaker 1: You know, she's crying. My cat made it back. 00:01:46 Speaker 2: He went hunting this morning and I haven't heard from him. 00:01:51 Speaker 1: Denise said Mike had left that morning, December 16th, to chase ducks on Lake Seminole, a 38,000-acre reservoir about an hour's drive northwest of Tallahassee. Mike was a dedicated hunter and angler, so his solo trip wasn't unusual. But when Mike failed to turn up for the couple's planned anniversary trip, Denise started to become worried. 00:02:12 Speaker 3: So I got a phone call Sunday morning, about 7 a.m., from another buddy that had been called and said that Mike hadn't shown up. And so I jumped in the truck and ran over there. 00:02:26 Speaker 1: That's Scott Dungy, one of Mike's close friends and hunting buddies. 00:02:31 Speaker 3: I figured he had maybe fallen in a hole or had fallen and hit his head and he was across the island or across the lake on one of the islands and that he needed to wake up and we would find him. 00:02:42 Speaker 1: News of Mike's absence quickly spread among Mike's other friends and associates. Clay Ketchum, Mike's employer, first heard the bad news from one of Denise's sisters. 00:02:52 Speaker 4: She said, Denise wanted me to call you and tell you that Mike went on a hunting trip yesterday and he hasn't come home yet. And she was getting ready to hang up. And I said, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, wait. You got to tell me more to the story. It was like pulling teeth to get information. It was so odd. She was just trying to give me a shortcut. 00:03:24 Speaker 1: Something was wrong, but Clay didn't have time to ponder the strangeness of this interaction. He, Damon, and Scott rushed up to Lake Seminole, where they joined dozens of volunteers and law enforcement personnel scouring the lake for any sign of Mike Williams. Denise didn't make the journey, but Damon says she was as upset as anyone about the absence of her husband. 00:03:46 Speaker 2: She was upset. 00:03:47 Speaker 1: I mean, she was crying. She's worried. 00:03:49 Speaker 2: I'm like, don't worry. We're going to find him. 00:03:51 Speaker 5: You know Mike. 00:03:52 Speaker 2: He's broke down. You know, he's stuck in the middle of the lake. He knows how to take care of himself. He's going to make it back in. 00:04:01 Speaker 1: Clay didn't say whether he had tried to reassure Denise's sister, but privately, he wasn't hopeful. 00:04:08 Speaker 4: Sometimes you just get phone calls and you get that phone call and you go, he's dead. There's no question in my mind he is dead. Something bad has happened to him and he's gone. 00:04:21 Speaker 1: Clay's premonition was dark, but it wasn't unfounded. Mike wouldn't have been the first solo hunter to get himself in trouble on the water. With the cold front that had moved in by Sunday morning, it was hard to imagine Mike surviving very long on the large lake. That is, if he was still on the lake at all. 00:04:40 Speaker 6: There was just a lot of things that nobody knew, not even Florida Game and Fish or anybody else that was happening. 00:04:48 Speaker 5: I would say within maybe the first week, we were just like, what is going on? 00:04:55 Speaker 7: Like, this is just not adding up. 00:04:57 Speaker 8: And I think that drives you to know that something's really wrong. Something bad happened when all of these people are trying to prove to you and gaslight you into believing that he got eaten by alligators. 00:05:12 Speaker 1: Like the holes that dot the bed of Lake Seminole, the disappearance of Mike Williams became darker and nastier the deeper investigators probed. They didn't know what they'd find at the bottom, and some eventually concluded that there was no bottom to be found. But others, including Mike's mother, never gave up. They knew something wasn't right, and they didn't rest until eventually they uncovered the muck and mire at the heart of what would become one of America's most famous cold cases. I'm Jordan Sillars, and this is Blood Trails, a duck hunter's best friend. Part One. The Lake. Scott Dungy wasn't a law enforcement officer, but no one searched harder for Mike in the days following his disappearance. Scott told me that what would have been great duck hunting weather made the search immediately difficult. It was just brutally cold. 00:06:13 Speaker 3: The wind was blowing 10, 15 miles an hour, 12 degrees, just brutally cold. You know, I knew time was of the essence, just given the environment. 00:06:26 Speaker 1: But that wasn't even the hardest part. Lake Seminole was an extremely difficult body of water to navigate, especially the portion where they believed Mike had been hunting. 00:06:35 Speaker 3: It was a flooded pecan orchard that was probably 100 to 150 yards wide by 1,000 yards long and tons of stumps about three inches, four inches below the surface of the water and then a solid layer of hydrilla right underneath that, so you couldn't see these stumps. People were running up on stumps, falling out of the boat. Even when we knew where they were at after being there a month, people were still falling out of the boat. So it was extremely treacherous. 00:07:13 Speaker 1: Divers couldn't see through the murky water, so search teams trolled back and forth, probing the bottom of the lake with PVC pipes. And we would all methodically. 00:07:23 Speaker 3: just move forward and walk up and down the boat, pulling until you, you know, hit something that gave back and didn't feel like a tree or a stump. 00:07:33 Speaker 1: You can imagine how Scott and the others felt doing this day after day, hoping to bump into their friend, but also desperately hoping not to. Here's Damon Jasper. 00:07:44 Speaker 2: We continue to go over there. And at some point you're in a boat with a stick and they're like gritting it off and you're just In the grounds, trying to find something soft that might be your buddy. 00:07:58 Speaker 1: There were a few times when Dame and Scott and the others thought they found something, but further investigation didn't uncover any sign of the missing hunter's body. However, not long after the search began, they did find one thing. But it left Clay Ketchum with more questions than answers. 00:08:16 Speaker 4: They found the boat. They found the boat, so they knew about it. You know, I don't know if you're a duck hunter at all or if you've never duck hunted, but it's a messy, nasty business. And I've never seen a boat that was used for duck hunting that wasn't just the bottom of it was just a mess. This boat pulls in and it's just like they dropped it off the trailer. 00:08:43 Speaker 1: The boat was found on the shore, not far from where Mike had parked his Ford Bronco, and it was remarkably clean. What's more, when officials inspected the gas tank to see how far it may have been driven, the tank was almost full. 00:08:56 Speaker 4: This was odd because, at this point, the most likely scenario was that Mike had fallen out of his boat. 00:09:16 Speaker 1: Mike's watercraft was really just a canoe with an engine hooked to the back. It was easy to imagine how he could have hit a stump in the darkness, fallen out, and sunk to the bottom as his waders filled with water. The problem was, Mike hadn't hooked up the kill switch that would have cut the engine if he had fallen out. How, Clay wondered, could the boat have gotten all the way back to the landing without running out of gas? 00:09:40 Speaker 4: And then they opened up the scabbard for the gun, for the shotgun wall, They pulled it out, and it was Mike's over-and-under chugger, and it was his pride and joy. He would have done anything to not mess up that gun. 00:09:59 Speaker 1: Duck hunting is tough on boats and guns alike. Most hunters use a shotgun. They don't mind getting a little beat up. So that expensive over-under was an odd choice for an experienced hunter like Mike. All of this was strange, but it could be explained. That was especially true if Mike's friends considered adding a scaly variable to the equations. 00:10:21 Speaker 3: I was adamant believers of Mike had fallen out of his boat. 00:10:27 Speaker 4: The waders filled up with water. 00:10:28 Speaker 1: He sunk. 00:10:29 Speaker 3: An alligator got him, took him somewhere and stuffed him. 00:10:33 Speaker 1: That would explain why there wasn't any sign of Mike. It could also explain why his boat was still so close to shore and why it didn't look like he ever really started hunting. Some question whether alligators feed in mid-December, and it is true that even in Florida, they're less active during the winter months. However, historic weather data shows that on Saturday, December 16th, the day Mike went missing, temps hit 75 degrees. The cold front didn't roll in until later. Daily highs the previous week had ranged from the mid-60s to the high 70s, so it's not implausible that Mike stumbled upon a hungry or territorial gator. 00:11:11 Speaker 2: You go out there and hunt, and when you're headed out in the morning, generally you've got a spotlight in front of the boat, and all you see is eyes of alligators everywhere. 00:11:20 Speaker 1: Of course, even if that was true, searchers still wanted to find whatever remained of Mike's body. Scott and the others scoured the lake for over two months, past Christmas and into the new year. They used underwater cameras, sonar, helicopters, everything they could think of to give Denise and Mike's family some closure. But they came up empty. As the weeks wore on, the alligator theory began to solidify in the minds of searchers and officials alike. Clay remembers getting a call from one of Mike's friends, a guy named Brian Winchester. 00:11:53 Speaker 4: And he says, hey, ain't your fish seem to believe that Mike's been eaten by an alligator? You know, and they've stuck him under a dam. How many alligators has he? You know, so we're waiting for spring. And I said, oh, that just makes me sick. And Brian says, oh, my gosh, yeah, it's just my awful fault. 00:12:17 Speaker 1: It was a heartbreaking situation all around. Denise was now a widow. Mike's 18-month-old daughter Ansley would never know her father. What should have been a harmless hunting trip had devastated the young family, not to mention Mike's friends who'd grown up with him in the Tallahassee area. By January of 2001, most of those friends and family had resigned themselves to the reality that Mike had died doing something he loved, but they might never really know how he passed away. But Not everyone agreed with that consensus. 00:12:50 Speaker 4: Cheryl was absolutely convinced that he, number one, she said he's not in that light. 00:12:56 Speaker 1: Cheryl is Cheryl Williams, Mike's mother. Cheryl didn't have any logical reason to believe that her son was anywhere other than Lake Seminole. Clay told me that most assumed the grieving mother just couldn't accept reality. But according to Cheryl's friend, Maria Denmark, Mike's mother wasn't operating within a reality most people could see. 00:13:16 Speaker 9: She said that when she went to Lake Seminole for that first time, she heard God tell her that he's not in the lake. 00:13:24 Speaker 7: You need to find him. He's not in the lake. 00:13:29 Speaker 1: Part two, the waiters. Almost everyone except Cheryl Williams believed that as the weather turned hot the next summer, Mike's remains would begin floating to the surface of Lake Seminole. Sure enough, In June of 2001, a fisherman found what appeared to be a treasure trove of Mike's possessions. 00:13:49 Speaker 3: The clothes were found, I believe, around during the summer in June. We got a call that some of the waiters had popped up right next to where we had marked that spot. And then we, myself and two others, went over there with a diver and found the jacket and the flashlights. 00:14:11 Speaker 1: At this point, you might be thinking, case closed. This is exactly what everyone expected would happen, and Scott said he took the discovery as proof that his alligator theory was correct. Cheryl Williams had told a story of Mike jumping into a pool with his waders on to practice taking them off in the water. He knew how to shed that clothing, which would explain why his remains weren't found in the same location. But his remains also hadn't been found anywhere else. Clay told me he talked about Mike's case with a forensic pathologist, a U.S. marshal, and a funeral director. They all said independently that even if he was attacked by a gator, some part of his remains would rise to the surface as the weather warmed up. 00:14:56 Speaker 4: And these same people said, whatever happened? And I said, never, never found. And they all kind of looked up and said, Most unusual. I'll never forget that, those words, those two words. And that's what every one of them said to a person. They said, most unusual. 00:15:20 Speaker 1: The notable absence of Mike's body still concerned his friends and family. But Damon said he could hardly believe that Mike had been wearing waders at all. 00:15:29 Speaker 2: He wouldn't have gone out there with his waders on. He was very safe about that kind of stuff. 00:15:35 Speaker 1: Duck hunters know how dangerous it can be to fall into deep water with waders on, and Mike had said as much to Damon just a few days before he went missing. 00:15:44 Speaker 2: This guy just preached to me seven days ago or whatever that we're going to drive all the way out in the middle of the lake, and then we're both going to wiggle into waders in basically a canoe, you know? So I was like, I don't think he went over with his waders. You know, I just don't see that happening. 00:16:03 Speaker 1: What's more, Maria told me that the waders themselves were in oddly good shape. 00:16:08 Speaker 7: And there's no, like, scum in them. 00:16:11 Speaker 10: In the Florida heat, that would be disgusting. 00:16:15 Speaker 7: It would have stuff all over it. 00:16:17 Speaker 9: And then when the diver found Mike's jacket and a fishing license on the inside, and the ink was still written well, and it's not like a. 00:16:27 Speaker 7: Normal plastic license. It was a paper one. 00:16:30 Speaker 10: How? 00:16:32 Speaker 7: There's no way. 00:16:34 Speaker 1: Scott also mentioned that Mike's flashlight was still working, which seemed unlikely if it had really been at the bottom of the lake for over six months. No one knew how to explain these discrepancies, but for some, they were enough to prove that Mike had died in that lake. 00:16:51 Speaker 2: That was the nail in the coffin to pay the insurance to get him, you know, marked as legally dead and then the insurance payout. 00:16:58 Speaker 1: Normally, when someone goes missing, it takes years for that person to be officially declared dead. There are many reasons for this, but one is that life insurance companies don't want to pay a claim for someone who just ran away. 00:17:11 Speaker 4: But it just, there was a lot of pressure, I think, on the court system to declare him dead because there was a beautiful young woman with her little baby in her arms saying, I need that insurance money. 00:17:28 Speaker 1: Mike had obtained a $ 1 million policy through his friend Brian Winchester, whose father ran a financial services company in Tallahassee. Brian's father pushed for the death certificate to be granted and the money to be paid out, which was part of the reason everything came together so quickly. Everyone felt bad for Denise. No one wanted to see her struggle financially, so if the discovery of Mike's waiters eased that pressure, most were happy to chalk it up to divine intervention. But Clay Ketchum wasn't so sure. When he heard about Denise's good fortune, he thought back to the day after Mike went missing. He and his wife Patty had driven over to the Williams house to see how Denise was doing. But when they got there, they could hardly believe what they were seeing. 00:18:13 Speaker 4: There was a lot of cars there, while the lights on and everything. And so we walk in and it is like they're hosting your Christmas party. It was like, The most bizarre thing we've ever seen. It was, you know, the Christmas tree was all lit up, all the presents everywhere, and people walking around with drinks in their hands and telling stories and laughing and things like that. 00:18:41 Speaker 1: Denise's mom called her daughter down to say hello to the Ketchums, but Denise only spoke for a few minutes before excusing herself. 00:18:48 Speaker 4: Patty and I got in the car and looked at each other and went, you got a big chitty ring. Wasn't that the oddest thing you've ever seen? 00:18:56 Speaker 1: When Clay heard how quickly Denise was able to secure Mike's life insurance payout, his mind went back to that night. And the oddly exuberant atmosphere of Denise's home was underscored just a few minutes later when they drove over to Cheryl Williams' house. 00:19:11 Speaker 4: Oh, there was a contrast. Oh my gosh. We pulled in. It was dark. Matter of fact, it was so dark we were wondering if anybody was there. 00:19:22 Speaker 1: Cheryl and Mike's brother, Nick, opened the door and invited them inside. 00:19:27 Speaker 4: It was a feeling you get when you go to visit someone who definitely knows they've lost a son. She was grieving. 00:19:38 Speaker 1: This was noteworthy because Mike had only gone missing the day before. It was still possible they'd find him alive, but Cheryl seemed to know something everyone else didn't. 00:19:48 Speaker 4: Cheryl was absolutely convinced that he, number one, she said he's not in that light. And she said, you know, she felt like Carol Clay had been involved. 00:19:59 Speaker 1: She didn't explain why she believed this, and Clay said he was skeptical. But a mother's intuition shouldn't be dismissed lightly. Cheryl may not have understood everything that was going on, but she'd heard rumors. Those rumors suggested that Mike's life wasn't as perfect as it appeared, and that darkness had been growing long before he'd left to duck hunt Lake Seminole that balmy December morning. Mike had lived in the Tallahassee area his entire life. He began attending a private school called North Florida Christian School when he was in kindergarten, and he stayed all the way through 12th grade. Scott Dungy transferred to North Florida Christian as a freshman, and he said Mike was one of his first friends at his new school. 00:20:48 Speaker 3: Very gregarious, outgoing, very unassuming, always positive. 00:20:54 Speaker 1: Mike was well-liked and what you might call a jack-of-all-trades. He could run with most of the cliques at the small school, including the hunters. 00:21:03 Speaker 3: Mike was a bit unique in that he had multiple friend groups, ones that he hunted with, ones that he played ball with, ones that he worked with. So he was involved in various friend groups. But his passion early on, it was pretty well known, was hunting. He taught me how to turkey hunt. He took me turkey hunting the first time that got me hooked. Took me duck hunting the first time. We ran against each other in student council and should have known better to run against Mike. He beat me pretty soundly. 00:21:41 Speaker 1: Denise, Mike's future wife, transferred to North Florida Christian as a freshman, and she and Mike hit it off almost immediately. 00:21:48 Speaker 3: I think they started dating either the end of our freshman year or beginning of our sophomore year, I believe. Pretty much all through high school. She was well-known, popular, pretty kind of intimidating. She intimidated me. She was tall, thin, very outgoing. Mike would do whatever she wanted done. So as long as that occurred, there wasn't ever any conflict. But no, their relationship was good. 00:22:20 Speaker 1: It was your. 00:22:21 Speaker 3: Typical petty little fights over books in the locker and messy lockers and where to go and, you know, where are you going to spend time with me and this weekend and, you know, probably the biggest fights they had were over, you know, him hunting and not being where she wanted him to be. So, you know, they had a really good relationship all through high school. 00:22:42 Speaker 1: Two of Mike and Denise's best friends were another couple named Brian Winchester, whose name you've already heard, and Kathy Thomas. The two pairs of couples dated in high school, and after college, they married their respective partners and remained in the Tallahassee area. You can imagine the bond they formed going through high school and college together and all marrying their high school sweethearts. For his part, Mike was determined to build a comfortable life for himself, Denise, and their baby daughter. 00:23:10 Speaker 4: He was a driven kind of guy. I mean, he really wanted to work and work very hard. 00:23:17 Speaker 1: Mike worked for Clay as a real estate appraiser, and he was dedicated to using that profession to build his fortune. Clay said Mike would often get to the office in the early hours of the morning and work until evening. Then he'd go home, eat dinner with his family, put his daughter to bed, and return to the office and work until after midnight. 00:23:36 Speaker 4: He was working like nobody we had ever seen. He was working because he acquainted money with success. And the reason was because The niece's sisters, one of them was married to an attorney and the other one was an engineer. And the whole family was just a bunch of professional folks. And I think he was driven by that. 00:24:04 Speaker 1: He wasn't working such long hours because he was struggling. Clay said Mike was good at his job. And by the time of his disappearance, he was handling a huge percentage of the company's business. 00:24:14 Speaker 4: He had a great personality. People liked him. You know, his common denominator with people was hunting. And so if he could find a client that we had that was a hunter, then they really connected. And in a lot of cases, he would find clients that had land that they would allow him to hunt on. So that was even a double benefit. 00:24:37 Speaker 1: Damon got to know Mike because he got a job at Clay Ketchum's appraisal company. Damon benefited from Mike's hunting connections, and he said they'd often combine a work trip with whatever hunting and fishing opportunities they could find in that area of Florida. 00:24:51 Speaker 2: Mike liked to work hard, play hard in that instance, and his play hard was hunting. Sometimes we'd meet up there at 4 a.m. and go on a duck hunt or a turkey hunt or sit in a tree stand, maybe run down to the beach and fish and then come back. 00:25:04 Speaker 1: And then, you know, he'd work all day. 00:25:06 Speaker 2: He was just kind of taking me under his wing, you know, Show me different things that I hadn't really, you know, done before, like turkey hunting. And, you know, that's when I got into duck hunting as well. 00:25:19 Speaker 1: You heard Scott Dungy say something similar. Mike was happy to share his passion for hunting with others. And Damon said he liked being out there with his friends just as much as he liked a successful hunt. Another of his hunting buddies was Brian Winchester. When Mike went missing, Clay's mind went back to a time several years prior when Mike fell into a different lake while hunting with Brian. 00:25:40 Speaker 4: Mike fell into what's called a gator hole. The water level was down, and he just looked and fell and dropped a shotgun. And the shotgun went to the bottom. He was able to grab a root and pull himself out, get his head up, and then Brian helped him get out of the gator. So there he is. His life has been saved, and he's just panicked, but he's got that gun in the bottom. 00:26:07 Speaker 1: What happened next illustrates Mike's ingenuity, but also his dedication to earning and not spending money. 00:26:14 Speaker 4: The mud is so soft, it's just almost impossible to get out through. So he devised a scheme to go to L.L. Bean and buy snowshoes. So he puts them on and he can step out into the mud on the lake and get back to the gainer hole where he can lean over, reach down in there and feel around And he found the tip of the shotgun and pulled it up, got back, closed off the snowshoes, and sent him back to L.O. Bain, got his money back. I'm telling you, that is tight. 00:26:52 Speaker 1: Mike was liked by his friends and colleagues, but I think the couples out there might have already picked up on some warning signs in his relationship with his wife. Mike was, by all accounts, hardly ever home, and that puts a strain on any relationship. Mike was driven to be successful, but Damon wonders if he also had his reasons for avoiding Denise. 00:27:12 Speaker 2: Maybe Mike just didn't want to be there. I can remember one time I went with him, and we visited during the day, and I don't even know why we stopped by the house, but we had to, and I was with him. And you could just see his face when he came back out. Like, I don't remember if he said anything, but you knew they had a big fight, you know? But in public, whenever you saw Denise... She's sweet as she can be. Always smiling, always happy. But I knew then that in that instance, you know, it wasn't always, you know, rainbows and kittens at the house. 00:27:49 Speaker 1: Money also seemed to be a major topic of conversation in that household. Clay told me the couple had a pact that they wouldn't spend more than $ 50 without running it by the other person. Maybe that's responsible financial planning, or maybe there was something else going on. 00:28:05 Speaker 4: Mike said, and Mike was very proud. He didn't talk a lot about his family relationship. But he said, you know, Mr. Ketchum, I need to talk to you. And he said, you know, we're pretty tight on money. And he said, we got the MasterCard bill. And it was a $ 3, 000 cash advance loan. 00:28:26 Speaker 1: This was back in the year 2000. So $ 3, 000 was an even bigger chunk of change than it is today. Clay also knew how careful Mike was with money. 00:28:36 Speaker 4: And I said, what the heck? I mean, the obvious question was, what did she buy for $ 3, 000? And he said she had to pay off a drug bill. And I said, a drug debt? And he said, yeah, her and Brian, which was his best friend, Brian had been supplying her with marijuana. And I said, okay. And I said, how is she consuming this marijuana? And I said, well, she's eating it in brownies. And I went, oh my gosh, I turned the call. And I said, this is nuts. 00:29:12 Speaker 1: This is nuts. 00:29:13 Speaker 4: She would be as big as a freaking bar in Williams if she was eating. 00:29:16 Speaker 11: $ 3, 000. 00:29:17 Speaker 4: Worth of marijuana. It can't happen. 00:29:21 Speaker 1: Clay believed Denise was buying stronger stuff than weed brownies. But wherever that money was going, you can imagine how it landed with a guy who would return a pair of muddy snowshoes to avoid an unnecessary expense. 00:29:34 Speaker 4: I'll tell you what, he said, I'm not going to have it. He said, so my plan is, is to divorce her, get custody of Angela. And, you know, we're not having this. 00:29:48 Speaker 1: As shocked as Clay was at this news about Denise, he advised Mike to take a deep breath and consider his options. A judge was unlikely to give Mike full custody of his daughter. It would be better for Ansley if her parents stayed together and worked out their problems, as serious as their problems might be. Mike seemed to be convinced by this advice, because just a few weeks later, he told his boss that things were looking better at home. 00:30:13 Speaker 4: And it wasn't long after that that he said, you know, I think things are better. We're going to go. We're going to try to have a more legit job. You know, they were supposed to go to a place in Apalachica. 00:30:35 Speaker 1: The couple was planning a getaway to celebrate their anniversary the same Saturday Mike disappeared. The high school sweethearts had hoped to restore their strained relationship. Instead, Mike never came home. And that's where his story might have ended. A young father and husband were fighting for his marriage and his family, tragically lost on his wedding anniversary. But Cheryl Williams knew that explanation was too simple. As the years dragged on, she refused to remain silent until law enforcement began to take a serious interest in Mike Williams' story. I got a call from my supervisor. 00:31:16 Speaker 6: Saying, telling me that I needed to go over to Tallahassee to talk to a person about the, and everybody referred. 00:31:27 Speaker 1: To it as the duck hunter. 00:31:28 Speaker 6: You know, there was obviously rumors about what happened to him and all of this. 00:31:34 Speaker 8: I was partnered with a FDLE agent. 00:31:38 Speaker 6: Me and him went over to Tallahassee to speak to Cheryl Williams. 00:31:43 Speaker 1: That's Derek Wester, who was at the time an investigator with the Jackson County Sheriff's Office. When he says FDLE, he's referring to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, the state-level crime-fighting agency. He and his partner went to visit Cheryl in 2004, four years after Mike had disappeared. 00:32:01 Speaker 6: So she goes into this great lengthy detail. You know, she's sitting there telling us this story. And of course, I'm taking handwriting notes. And she already had it typed up. So she probably had, I don't know, 25 pages of the notes that she's telling me already typed up. and me and the agent, the FDLE agent on the way back from Tallahassee, we got talking and, you know, it was believable and it raised a lot of red flags and a lot of suspicious activity after the initial search and. 00:32:34 Speaker 3: All was over with. 00:32:35 Speaker 1: Cheryl never thought Mike was in the lake, but her suspicions were piqued when she was informed that Denise had secured Mike's death certificate just a few months after he vanished. 00:32:45 Speaker 6: The way she got it, was odd to her because she wasn't notified of it. The only way she found out was because she knew somebody that worked at one of the insurance companies that had him insured, and that person told her. 00:32:59 Speaker 1: Denise didn't just have Cheryl's son declared dead without telling her mother-in-law. According to Maria, Cheryl's friend, Denise kept Ansley from seeing her grandmother. Cheryl ran a daycare from her home, and for many years after Mike's death, Denise took Ansley to Cheryl's daycare. But one day, that changed. 00:33:19 Speaker 12: Michelle had put something in the paper about Mike. Denise blew up on her and threatened to take the baby away if she kept trying to find Mike. So about five years old, I think, is when Denise ended up taking Ansley away. 00:33:34 Speaker 7: And that's when she started getting suspicious. 00:33:37 Speaker 10: Especially when it's, don't put Mike's picture in a paper. I don't want to see it anymore. That's got to raise every hair on your body. 00:33:47 Speaker 1: Everyone reacts to tragedy differently, and maybe Denise had other reasons for being upset at her former mother-in-law. But as Derek Wester continued to investigate Mike's widow, he found something that went beyond family squabbles. 00:34:01 Speaker 6: She lied on her presumptive death certificate filings. By how the law was written, she committed insurance fraud. 00:34:09 Speaker 1: When Denise filed a petition with the court to declare Mike dead, she said that Mike only had one life insurance policy with the Kansas City Insurance Company. But that wasn't true. Unbeknownst to anyone, Denise had kept paying another insurance policy with a different company. She didn't inform the court of this fact, which records proved constituted insurance fraud. The statute of limitations on that type of fraud is eight years, and only about five had elapsed. Derek and the other investigators knew they had time. And with that time, they discovered something else. 00:34:42 Speaker 6: We called Brian in to talk with us. And he told us what he was doing that day. 00:34:48 Speaker 1: Brian Winchester was Mike's close friend and frequent hunting companion. He told Derek that the day Mike went missing, he had planned to go duck hunting with his father-in-law, but he overslept. 00:34:59 Speaker 6: He said he woke up with the sun coming through the blinds. It was like, oh shit, you know, I just, I stood up my father-in-law. 00:35:05 Speaker 5: That's wild. 00:35:06 Speaker 6: He said, I got up, played with my dog until him and his wife and kid went to Cairo, Georgia to her family's Christmas. And then he got a phone call from somebody that Mike was missing. 00:35:23 Speaker 1: In the days after Mike's disappearance, no one bothered to check the whereabouts of his friends and family. Like many cases we cover here on Blood Trails, Mike's case was treated as a search and rescue operation, not a criminal investigation. Suspects weren't interviewed. Evidence wasn't collected. Alibis weren't checked. including the alibi of Brian Winchester. 00:35:45 Speaker 5: I cannot say that I ever remember waking up with him beside me in that bed. 00:35:51 Speaker 1: That's Kathy Winchester, who was Brian's wife at the time Mike went missing. When Derek and his colleagues asked her to confirm Brian's story, she couldn't. 00:36:00 Speaker 6: She said that her and Brian hadn't slept together in the same room probably since their kid had been born. She said when she woke up that morning, he was already gone. 00:36:13 Speaker 5: I assumed hunting because it was hunting season. You know, that is in my mind, like I assumed he was hunting. And I can remember about noon that day, Denise calling me and saying, you know. 00:36:30 Speaker 7: Have you heard from Mike? Do you know where Mike is? Do you know where Brian is? And I was like, I'm here at the house. I'm wrapping gifts. I don't know where anybody is. 00:36:39 Speaker 1: Kathy explained that Brian was supposed to be back from hunting with his father-in-law around 2 p.m. But contrary to what Brian had told investigators, he never showed up. She took their son up to her parents in Georgia, and Brian didn't arrive until later that afternoon. 00:36:54 Speaker 6: So, you know, based on that part of it, we know that he didn't tell us the truth. 00:37:01 Speaker 1: This put both Brian and Denise directly in the crosshairs of investigators. If Denise had lied to get Mike's death certificate, Could she be lying about anything else? And why would Brian lie about where he was the morning Mike went missing? Where was he really and what had he been doing all day? These questions were concerning, but they weren't the only reason Derek wanted to take a hard look at Mike's wife and friend. 00:37:26 Speaker 3: They were all best friends, the four of them. They did everything together. And when Brian and Kathy divorced, I figured that Brian and Denise would get together. 00:37:38 Speaker 1: Like Mike and Denise, Brian and Kathy had been together since high school, but their marriage fell apart in 2003, and Brian and Denise began dating soon after. They married in December of 2005, and many of their friends thought the pairing was natural enough. But those friends didn't know about Denise's insurance fraud and Brian's alibi. The combination of these things seemed like more than enough reason to keep the investigation moving forward. Mike's mother was hopeful she would soon get some answers. But she didn't. One year passed, then two, then three. Detectives said they were still working, but they didn't appear to be making any progress. Four years passed, then five. Brian and Denise were still living in Tallahassee. The newspaper ran articles about Mike's disappearance, and there was even a podcast. But they didn't offer much new information. Six years passed. then seven, then eight. Cheryl, Mike's mother, had never abandoned her campaign to find her son. She took out an ad in the paper every year on Mike's birthday asking for information about his case. She also took out a yearly ad to wish Ansley a happy birthday. 00:38:52 Speaker 6: She would go and put up signs on the streets of Tallahassee close to where Brian and Denise went to church. She would picket on the sidewalk on Sunday mornings with pictures of mine. 00:39:06 Speaker 9: She would do that in front of their church, like on the sidewalk, on the public road out in front of their. 00:39:13 Speaker 7: Church, she would do that. 00:39:14 Speaker 9: And pastors from that church and people that went there would come out and be like, you need to leave. 00:39:20 Speaker 7: You're crazy. Some of them would cuss at her. And she just kept fighting. She knew what she was doing and it worked. 00:39:27 Speaker 9: It would get them talking about it and probably Denise and Brian arguing about it and keeping Mike's face fresh so they can't forget him. 00:39:37 Speaker 1: This was either a righteous campaign to get justice for her son or the cruelest kind of harassment. Detectives had reasons to be suspicious of Mike's former wife and friend, but the general public didn't know who to believe. But then, on August 5th, 2016, 12 years after Derek and his colleagues launched their investigation, everything changed. 00:40:08 Speaker 9: The main milestone that I remember is when we found out Denise and Brian were going to get a divorce. 00:40:15 Speaker 13: And thinking, oh, that might finally crack. 00:40:18 Speaker 10: The case, something will come out of that. 00:40:21 Speaker 12: And then when Brian kidnapped Denise, I think that's when we all knew something bigger was going to happen. 00:40:29 Speaker 1: Brian and Denise's relationship had been on the rocks for a long time. They'd separated in 2012 after about seven years of marriage, and Denise filed for divorce in 2015. Brian was upset, to put it mildly. He thought they might be able to save their marriage, but his reconciliation strategy left something to be desired. Here's Denise talking with law enforcement about what happened. 00:40:52 Speaker 14: So I go out to my car to go to work. 00:40:53 Speaker 7: I work at FSU. 00:40:56 Speaker 14: So then I pulled out on Miccosukee Road. I was calling my sister, and this person starts climbing out of the very back. And I couldn't tell at first who it was, but then immediately I knew who it was. But I was screaming, and the phone helped me. I didn't know if she had picked up yet or not. So I was screaming, help me, and then he grabbed the phone. 00:41:16 Speaker 1: Brian had been hiding in the back of Denise's SUV for hours. He had a gun along with what Denise said looked like a bottle of bleach, some kind of metal tool and a plastic sheet. 00:41:27 Speaker 14: So then he goes, I'm going to FB and hurt you. 00:41:29 Speaker 4: If you don't, you turn here. 00:41:30 Speaker 14: And I kept one straight again. And then, and I turned around and I go, what do you mean hurt me? And he pulled out a gun, like, like I'm not a hunting gun, but like a gun he would kill someone with. And he put it right here in my ribs. He put it right here. And he goes with this. and he pressed it in the air. 00:41:47 Speaker 1: Denise refused to drive where Brian told her to. Instead, she pulled into a CVS parking lot and tried to calm her estranged husband. Brian said he wanted to talk about their divorce. He said he'd lost everything and was thinking about killing himself. Denise tried to mollify him, and he eventually calmed down. 00:42:05 Speaker 7: And then he starts crying. 00:42:06 Speaker 14: What have I done? 00:42:07 Speaker 15: What have I done? 00:42:08 Speaker 14: It's too late for us, and I know it's not. 00:42:11 Speaker 7: Just let me go to work, and I'll meet you later. 00:42:14 Speaker 6: I'm so sorry. 00:42:14 Speaker 7: I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry. 00:42:17 Speaker 1: Brian got out of the car and Denise drove away and called the police. As you might imagine, law enforcement was extremely interested in what had transpired. 00:42:26 Speaker 16: On this particular day in August, I'm on my way to work and my boss calls and says, hey, we need to talk as soon as you get here. And I get the heads up that this has to do with Mike Williams' disappearance. 00:42:40 Speaker 1: That's John Fuchs, the assistant state attorney in Florida's second judicial circuit. 00:42:46 Speaker 16: And we start talking about this and we're in a very unique situation in the fact that we have Denise Williams, the victim of a crime that happened where she is assaulted with a firearm and kidnapped. And then we have Denise Williams, the suspect in a murder. 00:43:04 Speaker 1: They tried to keep these two cases separate. But there was no denying that officials were eager to take advantage of this opportunity to speak with Denise about Mike's case. 00:43:14 Speaker 16: Denise, he was going to kill you. 00:43:18 Speaker 17: He's had control of you for years and years and years. He has ruined your life. You and I are the same age, but y'all sure don't look it. It has eaten at you and eaten at you. 00:43:29 Speaker 1: That's David McCraney, a Tallahassee Police Department officer who was married to one of Denise's sisters. 00:43:35 Speaker 14: I know. 00:43:36 Speaker 6: I know Denise. 00:43:39 Speaker 1: He did it. 00:43:40 Speaker 17: And you know exactly what I'm talking about. I don't think you did anything ever whatsoever to be held that over your head forever. And he was going to do it again. He wasn't going to kill himself, Denise. He was going to kill you so that you could talk about him later. That is the truth. 00:43:56 Speaker 1: You can hear how McCraney is trying to use Denise's kidnapping to get her to talk about Brian's role in Mike's death. It's not a bad strategy. At this point, Denise didn't have much incentive to protect her ex-husband. 00:44:09 Speaker 17: What did he ever say to you back then? 00:44:11 Speaker 14: Back then about Mike? 00:44:12 Speaker 4: About Mike. 00:44:14 Speaker 14: I never had any reason to believe that he would do that. 00:44:19 Speaker 17: I believe he had something to do with Mike. I absolutely believe it. 00:44:22 Speaker 15: I do not. 00:44:23 Speaker 14: But this, what you're talking about, has nothing to do with tonight. Tonight is what I'm worried about. 00:44:28 Speaker 1: Denise repeatedly denies Brian's involvement in Mike's disappearance and more than once redirects the conversation back to the kidnappings. But investigators refused to be put off. Later, an FDLE officer named Mike Levaney asked Denise where Mike might be buried. 00:44:43 Speaker 4: Where do you think Mike's buried at? 00:44:45 Speaker 14: Oh, I have no idea. 00:44:47 Speaker 4: Any speculation on that? 00:44:49 Speaker 14: On where he's buried? 00:44:50 Speaker 5: Buried. 00:44:51 Speaker 14: I mean, I believe. 00:44:52 Speaker 16: You don't really believe he died on a lake? 00:44:55 Speaker 4: I do. 00:44:57 Speaker 14: Why? I just always have. 00:45:01 Speaker 7: That's what I believe. 00:45:04 Speaker 1: Whether Denise knew anything about Mike's disappearance or not, she wasn't willing to throw Brian under the bus. But Brian wasn't so noble. Brian was facing life in prison for armed kidnapping. His attorney, a guy named Tim Jansen, approached John and the other prosecutors to see what kind of plea deal he could strike. 00:45:23 Speaker 16: And we met in my office, and Tim gave his spiel. You know, it's a domestic situation, lover's thing, et cetera, et cetera. I looked at Tim, I'm like, Tim, We believe he's got information on a missing person or a homicide. We want to know what it is. 00:45:40 Speaker 1: I didn't tell him any names. 00:45:41 Speaker 16: I'm like, if he wants to tell us that, we can talk about a plea. If he doesn't want to tell us that, then we're going to trial. And Tim looks at me and says, what homicide or what missing person are we talking about? And I said, Tim, if you don't know that, you're the only one in Tallahassee that does it. I think it was a month later, he came back and said, okay, if he does know something, and if he is inclined to tell you, how would we go about doing that which started the conversations of how we were able to get a proffer. 00:46:09 Speaker 1: A proffer is an interview where someone gives information about a criminal investigation, usually hoping to exchange that information for a lighter sentence. In Brian's case, his lawyer demanded a steep price. In exchange for Brian telling investigators what he knew about Mike's disappearance, John and his team agreed not to prosecute Brian for Mike's death. and not to seek a life sentence in Brian's kidnapping case. 00:46:35 Speaker 16: We had to obviously wrestle with that situation for a while here at the state attorney's office, and the ultimate decision was, if he gave us closure, we would grant him immunity from the homicide. We didn't see any other way around it to find out what had happened, so we made that unfortunate decision, but I also think it's the only one we could make. 00:46:59 Speaker 1: They knew that Mike's case was unlikely to be solved without a confession. They also knew that if Denise wouldn't turn on Brian after he kidnapped her and threatened to kill her, she'd never do it. So they cut the deal and set up the interview. 00:47:13 Speaker 16: Quite frankly, at that time, we thought he had information, but we didn't necessarily know whether he was a cause of it. We didn't know what his role was. All we know is there's this poor lady that wants to know what happened to her son. And is there a way we can possibly recover Mike and give her some sort of closure before, unfortunately, she passes away or something along those lines? But we really didn't know what anybody's role was or what even remotely happened. 00:47:41 Speaker 1: When Brian sat down to tell his story, John could hardly believe what he was hearing. That's next, after the break. Part 6, The Confession Brian was interviewed by two investigators for the state attorney's office, Tully Sparkman and Jason Newland. The interview was live streamed to an office nearby where other investigators watched remotely. Here's Jason. 00:48:11 Speaker 11: So we sat down and started this proffer and he starts to tell us, I mean, in details about how the relationship with the entity started. And I'm listening to Brian tell this story and I'm, It takes everything I have to not look at Tully and be. 00:48:31 Speaker 3: Like, are you kidding me? 00:48:33 Speaker 11: Like, this is insane. 00:48:36 Speaker 1: Brian explained some of what you already heard, but he also admitted what investigators and some of Mike's friends had come to suspect, that he and Denise were having an affair long before Mike disappeared. 00:48:47 Speaker 15: So I've known Denise my whole life, basically since preschool. Never really had any interest in her. Denise until 1997. My first marriage was in 1994 to Kathy. Mike and Denise were married same year. We started having an affair October 13th 1997. 00:49:21 Speaker 1: Brian has said elsewhere that he started looking at Denise differently when the two couples began discussing their sex lives in a way, in Brian's words, married couples shouldn't. They first kissed on that date in October of 1997 and things progressed from there. 00:49:37 Speaker 15: I quite honestly was somewhat content with the arrangement as far as me and Denise I wasn't looking or pushing to get a divorce I didn't want to get divorced and Denise made it clear she would never get divorced primarily because of appearances she is ultra concerned about the way that she appears to the world Their anniversary was also coming up and I think there was pressure from Mike on her that they needed to have another baby or something like that. 00:50:24 Speaker 17: There was just a lot of. 00:50:27 Speaker 8: Pressure. 00:50:29 Speaker 1: At some point in the year 2000, the couple started discussing how they might get out of their respective marriages. 00:50:35 Speaker 15: The two main scenarios that I can remember being discussed was one scenario was we all went out on a boat, the four of us. Mike and Kathy were pushed overboard. Denise and I found our way to safety, and that was one scenario that I said wasn't going to happen. The other scenario was a scenario where Mike and I went hunting, and there was an accident that At. 00:51:08 Speaker 1: This point, you might be asking yourself, how could someone prefer murdering her husband to divorcing him? We don't know the answer to this question, but Kathy offered one explanation in an interview with law enforcement. 00:51:21 Speaker 18: So would you say that. 00:51:25 Speaker 9: Having Mike killed or having Mike disappear would be easier on Denise based through the lens of her public image? 00:51:34 Speaker 7: Yes, because it made her a victim. It made her a widow. Instead of a divorced one. 00:51:44 Speaker 1: Brian claims he never considered killing Kathy because he didn't want to leave his son without a mother. You'll forgive me for taking that statement with a grain of salt, but whatever the reason, they opted for the latter of the two plans he mentioned. 00:51:56 Speaker 15: So the plan was I would meet Mike, go do the crime, then come back to town, meet Jimmy Aldridge, go hunting with him. He's my alibi. And the other part of it was Denise, we wanted to make sure that she had an alibi, but she was supposed to be at home alone with a baby. So the only way she could have an alibi was to make sure that she made phone calls. I believe it was supposed to be from her home number so that she could say that she was at home during that time. The plan that was discussed and come up with was that he was going to be wearing waders. And the belief was, somebody falls in the water with waders, you're going down. 00:52:53 Speaker 1: Jason told me that they spoke to Brian several times over the course of the next few weeks, and each time he offered additional information. His most detailed account came in court a few years later. In one moment, he explained how Denise justified this method of killing her husband. 00:53:09 Speaker 15: She felt better, I guess, about herself or we could feel better about ourselves if there was a chance that he could make it out of it. You know, I mean, I think there was even talk about, you know, well, it'll be up to God what happens and not us. 00:53:26 Speaker 4: It won't be a murder. It'll be, you know, an accident. 00:53:30 Speaker 1: Brian told Mike he'd found a new honey hole on Lake Seminole, but they'd need their waders to get out there. This would have been believable enough. Kathy said Brian duck hunted every day of the season, so I'm sure Mike was excited to check out the new spot his friend had found. 00:53:45 Speaker 15: We went out like we were going hunting. We got to the area where his waders and jacket were found. I got him to stand up, and I pushed him into the water. 00:54:04 Speaker 4: He got his jacket off. And his waders off. 00:54:12 Speaker 15: And he was in a panic, obviously. 00:54:19 Speaker 16: I was in a panic. 00:54:24 Speaker 15: I was driving the boat. And I didn't know what to do. 00:54:34 Speaker 1: Mike had managed to swim over to a partially submerged stump and cling to it. At trial two years later, Brian described what he did next. John Fuchs told me this was the first time Brian had told this part of the story in detail. 00:54:47 Speaker 19: He was in the water, and he was, like, struggling. 00:54:56 Speaker 4: And he swam over one of those stumps and held onto it. 00:55:01 Speaker 1: And he was panicking, and I was panicking. 00:55:06 Speaker 15: And none of this was like going well I thought it was gonna go. 00:55:09 Speaker 14: And I didn't know what to do. 00:55:12 Speaker 4: He started to yell. 00:55:14 Speaker 15: And I didn't know how to get out of that situation. 00:55:21 Speaker 4: And so I had my gun in the boat. 00:55:26 Speaker 19: So I loaded my gun. And I just, I made one or two circles around And I ended up circling closer towards him. And he was in the water. And as I passed by, I. 00:55:50 Speaker 2: Shot him. 00:55:52 Speaker 3: I tried to put myself in Mike's spot and just can't imagine what was going through his mind. You know, his best friend had pushed him out of the boat. 00:56:01 Speaker 18: You know, that was bewildering to him. And then he's holding on to a stump and and then is doing circles and dries up and shoots him in the face. 00:56:12 Speaker 3: I just, sheer terror of those last. 00:56:18 Speaker 18: Couple minutes, you know, haunt me to this day. 00:56:22 Speaker 1: Ryan was supposed to leave Mike in the water and pretend his friend had drowned. With a shotgun wound in Mike's face, that was no longer an option. 00:56:31 Speaker 16: So I. 00:56:34 Speaker 4: Found him in the water. 00:56:36 Speaker 15: And dragged him to the shoreline. I went and got my vehicle and brought it back to. 00:56:44 Speaker 5: Where we were. 00:56:48 Speaker 15: I backed my Suburban down to the edge of the lake and put his body in the back. And pushed his boat back out into the water. 00:57:10 Speaker 1: Brian drove his suburban home with Mike's dead body still in the back. He said he stuffed the upper half of Mike's body in a dog crate so it wouldn't bleed so much in his car. When he got home, he crawled into bed and pretended to sleep. Sometime later, he called his father-in-law, claiming he'd overslept. Of course, he still had a problem, namely his friend's dead body in the back of his car. He rushed out to Walmart to grab a tarp weights and a shovel. Then he drove down to a local duck hunting spot called Carr Lake, dug a hole, and put Mike's body inside. 00:57:44 Speaker 11: And we just kind of stopped. You know, we paused the interview and it's like, what just happened? And all of that was fine. And okay, you've admitted to the murder. The problem is the agreement we had with your attorney is we can't use anything against you. So I really need more than this. 00:58:03 Speaker 1: They wanted details to corroborate Brian's story, but mostly they wanted the location of Mike's remains. Brian said he was willing to lead them to the spot. 00:58:11 Speaker 11: And he's walking around, and we take him down into the woods, very short distance, like maybe 100 yards into the woods. And he's looking around, and I'll never forget him. It's like there were three trees right next to where I buried him. And what was he doing? Crazier is when Brian takes us up to where he buried Mike. It is a location that he actually continued to hunt for years. And he talked about how he hunted in a turkey stand not too far away. He's like, and I would look down over where I buried Mike the whole time. 00:58:50 Speaker 1: Brian wasn't the only one who'd been hunting nearby. 00:58:53 Speaker 3: His body was found on my turkey lease that I had had for five or six years. So it was very ironic that for four or five or six years I sat probably within 100 yards. 00:59:07 Speaker 17: Of Mike's body. 00:59:09 Speaker 1: It took nearly a week of digging to find Mike's remains. The area was covered in water, and they had to bring in pumps and dams to keep the water out of the hole. 00:59:18 Speaker 11: Because it was like, all right, day seven, we're running out of time here. It's either we either find it today or we're calling it quits. And just like a movie would do, you know, The tractor goes across and it. 00:59:30 Speaker 1: Hooks a tarp. 00:59:33 Speaker 11: We removed the tarp and actually saw it was obviously bones were inside of it. 00:59:38 Speaker 1: We took it. 00:59:40 Speaker 11: To the medical examiner's office where they conducted x-rays. And there's an x-ray of a glove with Mike's hand still inside of it in the ring and Mike's wedding ring still on. 00:59:53 Speaker 4: It's eerie. It's creepy. 00:59:55 Speaker 1: Investigators confirmed other elements of Brian's story as well. the affair with Denise, his movements the day of the murder, his Walmart purchase. They even found a guy who stumbled upon Brian as he was burying Mike's body. The deer hunter talked to Brian for several minutes, never suspected a thing, and in all those years, didn't put the pieces together. 01:00:14 Speaker 16: And then we announced it the day after Brian's sentencing that there was now, Mike Williams had been recovered and that he, it was now a homicide investigation. 01:00:24 Speaker 1: Brian was sentenced to 20 years in prison, along with 15 years of GPS-monitored probation for kidnapping Denise. He couldn't be charged with Mike's murder thanks to his plea agreement, but Fuchs and his team believed the price was worth it to give Cheryl the remains of her son. Here's Maria. 01:00:42 Speaker 7: I wish he had gotten longer, but I also am glad that Ms. Cheryl now knows what. 01:00:47 Speaker 9: Happened and that Ansley, too, knows what happened to her dad. And I'm glad some sort of truth is out there. 01:00:56 Speaker 8: And Mike's body has been able to be actually properly laid to. 01:00:59 Speaker 7: Rest instead of wrapped in a tarp under a lake. 01:01:05 Speaker 5: Ms. 01:01:05 Speaker 7: Sherrill was right all along. He was murdered. 01:01:08 Speaker 10: Like, he wasn't in that lake. He was actually murdered. 01:01:11 Speaker 4: Why? 01:01:12 Speaker 9: A lot of people on Denise's side, like her friends and her family and Ansley, don't see that Ms. 01:01:18 Speaker 10: Sherrill's not the crazy one because she was. 01:01:21 Speaker 7: She was right. 01:01:29 Speaker 1: Part 7. Partial Justice. Brian couldn't be charged with killing his friend, but he maintained from the beginning that he didn't act alone. 01:01:39 Speaker 15: So I had planned to take this trip with Mike. Denise knew everything that was planned. 01:01:48 Speaker 16: Now what do we do to build a case against Denise? 01:01:54 Speaker 1: They built that case over the course of the next six months. And on May 8th, 2018, Denise was arrested at Florida State University, where she worked as an accountant. 01:02:04 Speaker 9: That day, I got a call from somebody and they were like, why didn't you tell me Denise was arrested? 01:02:10 Speaker 7: And I was like, what do you mean? 01:02:11 Speaker 10: And I looked it up and I can't tell you how many. 01:02:14 Speaker 8: Times we've watched that per walk from her at FSU from getting arrested and having to walk to the car. 01:02:22 Speaker 2: You know, we're like almost, what, 15, 20 years down the line at this point, like, very excited. And then when Denise got arrested, Perp walked out. There was some satisfaction, you know, that we were going to find out what happened with Mike. 01:02:39 Speaker 1: Denise was charged with first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, and accessory after the fact. Her trial began just a few months later, in December of 2018. And John's case rested almost entirely on Brian's testimony. 01:02:54 Speaker 16: And it all came down to whether or not they were going to believe Brian. We've got to prove and make people believe that what Brian is telling is true. 01:03:02 Speaker 14: And why? 01:03:03 Speaker 1: Proving his affair with Denise was easy enough. Brian had kept a briefcase full of letters, photos, and other evidence of their relationship. At trial, Brian explained how the pair had discussed Mike's death, their plan to give themselves alibis, and their promise to each other to never tell anyone what really happened. Brian said he never told Denise exactly how he killed her husband, but even this statement was evidence that Denise knew Mike had been murdered. 01:03:32 Speaker 15: I tried to tell her about it one day, and she did not want to know the details. 01:03:37 Speaker 3: She told me that she assumed. 01:03:41 Speaker 15: That obviously when his body was never found, that what we had planned did not happen. and that it never made sense to her that I was able to get to the shoreline, but that it was okay, and we were forgiven, and we were like David and Bathsheba, and God was going to forgive us, and we didn't have to tell anybody about it. 01:04:05 Speaker 1: While Denise may not have known all the details, she was, according to him, just as responsible for Mike's death. In one interview with law enforcement, he describes why he was so angry about their divorce settlement. 01:04:18 Speaker 15: I quite honestly didn't feel like her proposed settlement was fair to me considering what she had me do for her with regards to Mike. I gave up half of my relationship with my son to be with her. 01:04:38 Speaker 1: You can likely guess from this statement how Denise's defense portrayed Brian and his testimony. 01:04:44 Speaker 16: They're trying to say that Brian is a disgruntled ex-husband, and he is out there to get Denise because she had him arrested. He was a crazy ex-lover, a jealous lover, all of those things. So this was all about revenge on his part. But it didn't ring true because, again, our investigation, that initial interview, was clearly not conducted for the purposes of getting evidence on Denise. It was Here's what happened. And then we take a pause and we come back and says, now let's talk about what Denise did. 01:05:19 Speaker 1: John told me that when the jury left the courtroom to deliberate, he wasn't optimistic. Their case rested on the testimony of a man who'd lied for 20 years about murdering his best friend. But then the jury submitted a question to the judge about the homicide charge and John's cynicism turned to hope. 01:05:38 Speaker 16: And I leaned down to him like, guys, I think we did it. I think we're going to get guilty. And we're all like, yeah. And it was within an hour they were back. And they read out the verdict as guilty. 01:05:52 Speaker 1: The jury found Denise guilty on all three charges and sentenced her to life in prison without parole. Cheryl Williams declined to talk to me in a recorded interview, but Maria was with her that day. 01:06:06 Speaker 13: Her jaw just dropped and she I'm sure she was just beyond shocked that we finally had gotten to that day. But then also that was her former daughter-in-law. So there's got to be some hard emotion with that. And she probably felt relief that she had been proved right after all of these years. I went to her house after, and it was just definitely the best day probably to come out of all of this bad. Um, seeing justice actually be served. 01:06:41 Speaker 1: Cheryl was proved correct, and so were her tactics. 01:06:45 Speaker 15: When we would talk about Mike, we usually wouldn't say Mike, we would usually say Cheryl, because Cheryl was the one that kind of kept the investigation going and prompted everything. 01:06:57 Speaker 1: I have no doubt that Cheryl's picketing outside Brian and Denise's church sparked some of these conversations about Mike. We don't know whether this pressure factored into the deterioration of their relationship, but as you just heard, Mike's mom had clearly gotten into their heads. Everything seemed to be moving in the right direction, at least from the perspective of Mike's friends and family. But then. 01:07:22 Speaker 16: They appeal it and say that because she didn't have any involvement. 01:07:29 Speaker 17: In the murder. 01:07:30 Speaker 16: Itself, that... She should not have been guilty. 01:07:34 Speaker 3: Of the murder. 01:07:36 Speaker 1: No one claimed that Denise was present for Mike's murder, but she was still convicted of that crime because, according to the prosecution's theory, she'd helped the murder happen. 01:07:45 Speaker 16: She's the one that insisted him go on their anniversary, go duck hunting with their permission. She's the one that set all of this in motion. There was no way that he gets to go duck hunting with his buddy without talking to his wife and his wife insisting that he's able to go. 01:08:01 Speaker 1: I don't know whether there were any married hunters among the justices on the appeals court. If there were, I think they might have ruled differently. But they ultimately agreed with Denise's defense attorneys. They said there was insufficient evidence to prove Denise participated in Mike's murder and revoked her life sentence. 01:08:19 Speaker 16: To me, that's like saying, hey, I can hire someone to kill my ex-wife and that person kills my ex-wife because I wasn't there that day. and hadn't paid them any money yet, that now I'm not. 01:08:33 Speaker 17: Guilty of that. 01:08:35 Speaker 16: I don't agree with it in any way, shape, or form. 01:08:36 Speaker 4: She was there. 01:08:37 Speaker 16: I don't agree with it, but that's what they did. 01:08:40 Speaker 1: While Denise was relieved of her life sentence, the judge upheld her conspiracy to commit murder charge, for which she was sentenced to 30 years in prison. Her projected release date is 2046, when she will be 76 years old. 01:08:55 Speaker 9: That was definitely disappointing because Michelle never wants her out of, nobody wants Denise out of prison. 01:09:01 Speaker 7: She needs to stay there. 01:09:02 Speaker 8: I don't have any good words, so I just, I hope that her life stays in prison for the rest of her life. 01:09:11 Speaker 10: I hope all of her days are there. 01:09:18 Speaker 1: Part 8 God, family, and hunting. Justice was imperfect in the murder of Mike Williams, but it was better than the status quo. The two people at the bottom of Mike's murder are both behind bars. Cheryl Williams was able to bury her son and remains a testament to everyone who's ever advocated for a lost or murdered loved one. 01:09:41 Speaker 11: If it weren't for Cheryl, and this case did not gain the publicity that it gained, I am afraid it would have faded in time. Gone into the files of, you know, missing person declared dead by the court. 01:09:55 Speaker 1: Jason Newland isn't alone. Everyone I spoke with, investigators, prosecutors, Mike's friends and family, everyone credited Cheryl's tireless efforts for getting justice for her son. I asked Maria how Cheryl is doing these days, and Maria said she's staying strong as usual. 01:10:12 Speaker 7: She's doing pretty good. 01:10:13 Speaker 9: She has learned what Alexa is, and she has learned that she could ask it who Jerry Michael Williams is, and it'll tell her about her son. 01:10:24 Speaker 7: And she has a lot of people that love her and check in on her. 01:10:27 Speaker 1: Ansley, Mike's daughter, still hasn't gotten in touch with her grandmother. She's in her late 20s by now, but you can imagine how difficult her life has been, especially the last few years. 01:10:38 Speaker 9: There's probably not really any amount of therapy you can have to... get over that your mom and stepdad killed your dad and then raised you. 01:10:46 Speaker 7: And lied to you your whole life. 01:10:49 Speaker 10: But I really, I don't want her to ever miss out on Ms. 01:10:51 Speaker 4: Cheryl. 01:10:52 Speaker 7: So I really hope that one day she gets to talk to. 01:10:55 Speaker 10: Her and know her because Ms. Cheryl is really great. So I really hope Ansley will come around one. 01:11:01 Speaker 7: Of these days. 01:11:03 Speaker 1: As for Mike's friends, they've had their own struggles to process. Scott Dundee's belief that Mike had drowned in the lake put a wedge between himself and Mike's mother. He defended Brian and Denise from Cheryl's attacks and said he once called Brian to warn him that officials were investigating him. Now he's had to admit he was wrong, which, to his credit, he was quick to do in our conversation. 01:11:25 Speaker 3: What I believed was different from what others believed. So thankfully Cheryl was, you know, mother's intuition is never wrong. 01:11:38 Speaker 1: We could spend the next three episodes excavating the filth that led Brian and allegedly Denise to kill their friend and husband. But rather than focusing on the sordid details that led to Mike's death, Scott prefers to remember Mike for who he was in life. But I wanted to end with that and to just let you kind of say, here's who my friend was and here's how I hope he's remembered. 01:12:05 Speaker 3: Yeah, it's... It's hard to get through. Mike was a special person. He truly was. Never had a bad thing to say about anybody. Always positive. Always there to lend a hand and help out where needed. And very much a family man. All he wanted was, he had a plan. 01:12:37 Speaker 1: For his life. 01:12:39 Speaker 3: He put God first, family second, and hunting third. And pretty much nothing else mattered other than those three things. So just a genuine, genuine good person. 01:13:02 Speaker 1: Thanks for listening to this episode of Blood Trails. If you'd like to see images from this case, including of Mike, Brian, and Denise, head over to themeateater.com slash bloodtrails and click on the case file for this episode. You can also see many of these images by watching this episode on YouTube at Blood Trails TV. While you're there, you can watch the video version of every previous episode. And of course, don't forget to subscribe to be notified about future releases. Huge thanks to everyone who spoke to me on the record. Clay Ketchum, Damon Jasper, Scott Dungy, Maria Denmark, Derek Wester, John Fuchs, and Jason Newlin. Many of these folks have been interviewed about this story before, so I appreciated them giving me some of their time. If you like what we're doing with these stories, check out our new t-shirts and hoodies at the link in the episode description. They're designed by our very own Hunter Spencer and feature a hound dog, With the text, the trail never lies and nothing stays buried forever. Follow the sign. I think they're pretty slick, so check them out. As always, if you have any thoughts or comments on this episode or know about another story you think we should cover, send me an email at bloodtrailsatthemeateater.com. See you next time. Stay safe out there.