MeatEater, Inc. is an outdoor lifestyle company founded by renowned writer and TV personality Steven Rinella. Host of the Netflix show MeatEater and The MeatEater Podcast, Rinella has gained wide popularity with hunters and non-hunters alike through his passion for outdoor adventure and wild foods, as well as his strong commitment to conservation. Founded with the belief that a deeper understanding of the natural world enriches all of our lives, MeatEater, Inc. brings together leading influencers in the outdoor space to create premium content experiences and unique apparel and equipment. MeatEater, Inc. is based in Bozeman, MT.

Wired To Hunt

Ep. 1096: Foundations - Personal Hunting Ethics and the Changing World of Whitetails

Hunter drawing a bow in woods; overlay text "WIRED TO HUNT FOUNDATIONS with TONY PETERSON"; left text "MEATEATER PODCAST NETWORK"

Play Episode

16m

Personal hunting ethics vary by individual, but each one of us should try to find our own lines in the sand and then hunt accordingly. This is a great way to learn to truly enjoy each moment in the woods, and not focus so heavily on the end result of killing our target deer.

Connect with Tony Peterson and MeatEater

Tony Peterson on Instagram and Facebook

00:00:01 Speaker 1: Welcome to the Wired2Hunt Foundations Podcast, your guide to the fundamentals of better deer hunting. Presented by First Light, creating proven, versatile hunting apparel for the stand, saddle, or blind. First Light, go farther, stay longer. And now, your host, Tony Peterson. 00:00:19 Speaker 2: Hey everyone, welcome to the Wired2Hunt Foundations Podcast, which is brought to you by First Light. I'm your host, Tony Peterson, and today's episode is all about ethics in whitetail hunting and where this whole thing is kind of headed. I know I should probably be talking about the rut right now and how you can still catch it in the upper Midwest if you look real hard. Or, you know, if you're down south somewhere, you should be giddy because it hasn't hit yet. But I'm going to switch gears and talk about something totally different just because I think it's important to take stock in ourselves individually and as a group. That's what this episode is all about, so I hope you enjoy it. One of the camera guys I film with a lot is a good friend of mine, and he and I were sitting in a tent after a very exciting night a couple weeks ago. We'd paddled our way into some landlocked public land in Minnesota, set up that night, and almost immediately saw a doe. And then I caught a glimpse of a white rack and knew instantly I'd shoot that deer if it came in. Well, after a few snort wheezes, he did, and he put on a hell of a show along the way. The good thing about calling to deer is that sometimes they just come right in. The bad part about calling to deer is that when they do come in, they're looking for other deer, and this buck wanted to see who was jawjacking him up. Well, he got to about 22 yards, quartered hard toward us, and looked up. One thing that's really tough about filming whitetails, especially on public land, is that hiding two full-grown guys from those deer is just generally not that easy, and that old buck picked us off. He stomped a couple of times, and he turned to leave. That's when I drew and shot, and the arrow buried up to the fletching, and he took off, but the entrance was super high. I knew right away that I was very likely dealing with a one long hit, which in my experience is like a coin flip on odds of recovery. We reviewed the footage about 700 times in the tree and saw that not only did my arrow actually hit a little twig and kind of kick up enough to cost me like four inches of elevation on my entrance, but also that that buck dropped hard for obvious reasons. I don't say that to give myself any excuses, just that it's what happened and I know it because I got to see it in slow motion even if my brain didn't register it in real time. I knew that buck would drop at the shop. He was on red alert. I knew that I was shooting over a little shrub that if I had been on private would have been cut down and not in my best shooting lane. I knew a lot of things, including that I was in for a long night and a longer day, most likely. And unfortunately, I was right. When we were blood trailing that buck and he had made it onto private land, I tried to call the number on the posted sign, but the number was disconnected. So we walked the perimeter and by some miracle, that buck wandered back onto public and we found the blood. We followed it a long, long ways after that until he went back into private again. The distance traveled was a shade over a mile. That deer went into a place that was clearly managed for big deer. You know, the recovery options for getting to where we were were super limited. And the truth was that I felt like we were following a living deer. I told myself that I had definitely read somewhere that one long-hit deer that make it 12 hours have a really good chance of surviving. But I can't remember if that's even true or not, or if my brain just conjured that up to make me feel better. Losing any deer sucks. Losing a big public land buck sucks a lot. Losing one on film really sucks, but maybe not for the reasons most people think. Yes, not getting a show out of a trip is kind of like You know, flying a little crew out to a job site somewhere to offer up a competitive bid and then going home only to find that the contract went to someone else. The money invested in the potential for income is gone. And if you're the guy who is responsible for lots of money spent, but not lots of money made, eventually you'll be the guy who doesn't have any money because you don't have a job. Now here, we don't really generally bury footage like that because we like to show real hunting. That's one of the things I really like about working here, but also one of the things that I hate. Because I have to live with that for a year and then live with the fallout when a couple hundred thousand people see hours and hours of blood trailing reduced to a couple minutes of footage. I'll hear all about taking an unethical shot and not giving that animal the effort I should have, you know, from people who weren't there and who also really aren't judged on their actions in the stand. And honestly, from their perspective, I totally get it. One of my favorite pastimes to do when I'm on the road and watching, you know, regular TV in a motel somewhere is is to put on a sportsman's channel and talk mad shit about whatever show is on. It's fun to feel superior to other folks, and it's something that is innate in us as humans. We have to consciously check that impulse, and it's one that doesn't easily go away. I've been thinking about that a lot, how that whole thing will play out, and how often we say things like we only kill what we eat. We only take 100% sure thing shots. We give it every ounce of effort we can for recovery, and we respect the animals that we hunt. And then I thought, That's such bullshit. Maybe we do that with deer. Maybe. But what about when a coyote walks in? I personally don't shoot at coyotes or any other critter anymore that I don't want to eat just because it happens to walk by me while I'm hunting, but I feel like I'm kind of in the minority there. Now, I don't care that you shoot coyotes. I don't. I just think it's weird how we are so vehemently against them, you know, for eating deer, which is what we do. And I think it's crazy that modern deer hunting is often centered around building a deer oasis with as artificially high of a density as we can get, and then being surprised that the other things that eat deer suddenly show up, including neighbors on fence lines. Now, this is a tricky one because if you're not shooting across the fence line, who really cares? What are you going to do? But people do care. And our focus on trophy bucks has made this worse, in my opinion. This is the crux of the lively debate my cameraman and I got into in the tent one night during that hunt. Because he has a business where he consults with landowners who want to turn their properties into a little deer paradise. And he's good at it too. He knows a ton about food plots and native browse and a hell of a lot of stuff that I wish I knew. He knows more than almost anyone I've ever met on that topic. He also didn't really start bow hunting hard until like 2009. So the world of whitetails that he knows is not really the world of whitetails I know. And we talked about that a lot. I told him I thought deer hunting was more enjoyable when we didn't have trail cameras and a host of other technologies. And every deer that walked down the trail was a mystery and a hell of a nice surprise. But he responded by saying, yeah, but that was back when everyone shot dink six-pointers. He's not wrong. Killing any buck with a bow when I started out was a much different deal than it is today. But we didn't care. No one had really started to manage deer and try to create a big dumb herd of all their own to selectively take the biggest bucks from your deer. There weren't 15-year-olds out there then talking about 200-inch bucks. And if I'm being honest, I doubt anyone would have believed 200-inch bucks really existed outside of a few that were killed and made very famous. I told him that his business and the general move to manage deer, which is really just a strategy to produce big bucks and keep them from everyone else, hasn't done us that many favors. to which he countered by saying, if you have a neighbor doing that, you reap the benefits because the bucks on theirs could walk onto yours. And that's true. That's absolutely true. Now, that neighbor might not let you blood trail one on his, and if he's a high-profile TV hunter with enough money, he might just throw up a 10-foot fence between your land and his, but in general, the spillover effect is real. Now, that guy might not also let anyone else hunt ever on his land, which is the thing that bothers me the most about this direction that we are headed. And it echoes the comments you hear a lot about us being in a K-shaped economy, which means if you're in the bottom half, you're probably going to keep going in the wrong direction financially. But if you squeak into the top half, the likelihood of your net worth going up is pretty high. Now, if you have money and you love deer, you can do a lot with that. You have options. If you don't have a lot of money and you love deer, you don't have as many options. That's life. And it's not ever going to be fair. But that also doesn't mean that our nonstop obsession with bigger and bigger deer hasn't contributed to a lot of negative stuff. And my buddy told me that he believes that if you love it enough, you'll find a way to get on some land. You'll lease it, you'll buy it, whatever. That's true in his experience. But some folks, by no fault of their own, get a rough start in life that they just won't overcome. And to sort of drive that point home, when I was on that very hunt where I lost that buck, I got a text from my sister that said one of our cousins had died from liver failure. She drank herself to death, in no small part due to having an alcoholic father and being born in a tiny, failing mining town in northern Minnesota, where the options for employment are very limited. And the general pastime for a lot of folks is to drink to escape. Look, no judgment here. I did that for nearly two decades. And yeah, she could have quit. She could have overcome it. All that. But what we can do isn't always what we are really capable of. And it's no small feat when the odds are not in your favor, you know, starting at a young age. So just curiously, I asked him, hey, did you ever drive drunk when you were young? You know, in high school, whatever. Or maybe spend the night with a lady in a less than cautious manner. Did you ever get cancer? I won't tell you his answers, but my point isn't that we shouldn't be able to do what we please and buy land and keep everyone out. My point was that that very trend is going to cost us a lot of hunters in the long term. And yes, I get it. I'm a part of that trend and have been for a very long time. He pointed that out to me and he was wrong. I've written for a paycheck a lot of my life and done plenty of things in the hunting industry strictly to get paid. I mean, I mean this like truly, I love you guys. I love the audience for this podcast, but if I didn't have to do this or ever film a hunt again, I definitely wouldn't. I'd write though, but that's a different thing for me. Anyway, he and I went back and forth, and it was honestly a really fun debate. We talked about our favorite styles of hunting, our personal ethics, and it led to all kinds of back and forth. I told him that I thought putting in food plots and bedding areas and then peppering the place with cell cameras is hunting, but, you know, kind of. He said not everyone can go out and hunt public land and just try to find them, and not everyone should have to. I agreed completely and said so. I also said that for me, the purest form of what I can get out of deer hunting these days is that, And it's why I do it so much, even though I could kill bigger deer much more easily in a lot of other ways, which is true. But then he said something that stopped me dead in my mental tracks. He said, why is hunting a food plot any different than hunting a mineral site for cattle on public land in Nebraska? You see, he and I had hunted together there in September. We had found a small waterhole the deer were hitting and it was covered. So you couldn't really tell, but it looked like one of those cattle mineral sites just tucked into the middle of nearly 100,000 acres of sand hills and pines. And I said, well, it's different because I didn't put it there. I didn't do anything to alter their travel or try to force deer behavior. I was just dealing with what I was like dealt by the situation. I went in to check a stock tank. for tracks and I found that spot. But he couldn't understand how I viewed that any differently than someone else putting in a food plot and hunting it. And as much as I tried, I couldn't convince him that they were different. It was one of those moments like, get off my lawn. You know, like you just kind of have them more frequently as you get older. He has only known food plots and trail cameras and trophy deer management. And that's the lens through which he views hunting. Those are the parameters upon which he frames his personal ethics. And let me say this, he's very ethical. I've hunted with him a lot, and there's a reason I almost always request him for my filming projects. But his views on it and mine are quite a bit different, which was just interesting to me. And we covered all the hot topics in this arena, and he mentioned something about cell cameras and said, you know, cell cameras are great, but live stream cameras is too far. And I countered by saying, cell cameras damn near are live stream cameras these days. And I know they're not technically, but Considering you can get a notification almost instantly, it's not that far apart. But he said it's still different and that's unethical. And I asked him how many cameras he has up just for the hell of it. And he said 40. He then followed that up by saying they were spread out on several properties. But the whole time we were hunting, I watched him check those cameras. And at one point he said, there's a small buck headed my father-in-law's way. And I just thought, man, that's kind of crazy that we can know that now basically in real time. The question is, is it ethical? I don't know. I know the generation starting out right now will absolutely believe it is. And the older guys like me might not. I know that I use cell cameras and check mine religiously and love them. But for some reason, not having 40 out makes me feel more ethical than him. But there are guys out there who have two cameras or none who would look at me like I'm unethical. And from their perspective, they're right. I think about my daughters hunting with crossbows. They're so accurate, it's scary. and how some places where we hunt, baiting is totally legal. I think about the negative interactions I've had with landowners over the last 10 years, and almost every one of them was tied to a big buck somehow. I think about how we are exposed to so much hunting content now, and how normalized long shots with archery equipment and firearms are, and where the lines on ethics fall there. I think about the video I saw of someone in a tree stand with an opossum beneath him recently who threw his knife and hit it, luckily with the handle and not the blade. then he posted it for the world to see. And it goes to show, as much as we say we love the animals and respect them, that often boils down to mostly five and a half year old bucks and not much else. There is a theme I try to hammer home with this podcast and in my writing, which is that we should just try to be better at this stuff. The act of improving yourself is important. Maybe one of the most important things you can do as a human in hunting, in life, in whatever. I feel like we're all struggling these days and finding happiness in anything is challenging. but the search is good for us. And so is the exercise of trying to figure out how to hunt that makes us feel good about ourselves. Now, I know what makes me happiest in the deer woods, and it kind of sucks because it comes at a great expense generally, takes a lot of time, and exposes me to a ton of frustration and failure, both of which I'm not great at handling. But the reward for doing it the way that makes me feel good about it is one that I'm always chasing, and I kind of hope I always do. I think we should all think about that. Because right now in the deer world, the focus is so heavily on the end result that I sometimes think we forget that we actually just like to hunt deer. And sometimes we need to sit in the woods when we don't have the highest odds of killing a giant because it's the only way to wash off the BS of daily life. I think we should all try to recognize what choices and what actions we have taken in the deer woods that have made us feel better about ourselves or worse. The truth about this stuff is that it's freeing to care a little less about inches of antler and a little more about what it means to be able to sit in the woods at all, anytime during the deer season, with the feeling that we are doing things our way. However, it may shake out. We can feel good about it when we hike back to the truck in the dark. I think it's important for all of us to go through that, find our line with our personal ethics and stick to them. And those are going to change over time. And they're not going to be the same as everyone else's. And it doesn't matter. This is for us. as individuals. So do that. Get out there. Stay safe. Use the rest of your season. Come back next week because I'm going to talk about losing deer that we hit and everything that goes along with that. That's it for this week, my friends. I'm Tony Peterson. This has been the Wired to Hunt Foundation's podcast. As always, thank you so much for your support. If you need some more hunting content, you know where to go. TheMeatEater.com. We drop new films. I have a new film coming out that is different from anything we've ever done. I'm super proud of it. I'm terrified of it. But you're going to get to see it very soon. We have... tons of podcasts not only new episodes on your favorite feeds but we are dropping new shows quite often go check them out at themeateater.com while you're there if you want to read about you know some how-to stuff on how to kill a deer kill a grouse whatever or just brush up on the latest conservation news and the latest news in the world of hunting and fishing we have you covered themeateater.com go check it out

Presented By

Featured Gear

Camouflage hunting pants with cargo pockets and vertical thigh zippers On Sale
Save this product
First Lite
$129.50 $185.00 -30%
Shop Now
FIRST LITE camouflage Transfer Pack backpack with zippered top pocket and compression straps
Save this product
First Lite
$325.00
Shop Now
C1 Fiber climbing stick in Specter camo with two black serrated step brackets
Save this product
Timber Ninja Outdoors
$195.00
Shop Now
Men's Kiln Hoody On Sale
Save this product
First Lite
$120.00 $150.00 -20%
Shop Now
First Lite Kiln men's long johns, brown base layer with waistband reading FIRST LITE On Sale
Save this product
First Lite
$77.00 $110.00 -30%
Shop Now
First Lite Kiln 250 camouflage beanie On Sale
Save this product
First Lite
$28.00 $40.00 -30%
Shop Now

While you're listening

The comments section requires Functionality cookies. Please enable Functionality cookies in Cookie Settings to view this content.

Save this episode