MeatEater, Inc. is an outdoor lifestyle company founded by renowned writer and TV personality Steven Rinella. Host of the Netflix show MeatEater and The MeatEater Podcast, Rinella has gained wide popularity with hunters and non-hunters alike through his passion for outdoor adventure and wild foods, as well as his strong commitment to conservation. Founded with the belief that a deeper understanding of the natural world enriches all of our lives, MeatEater, Inc. brings together leading influencers in the outdoor space to create premium content experiences and unique apparel and equipment. MeatEater, Inc. is based in Bozeman, MT.

Bear Grease

Ep. 525: People of the High Arctic - Survival, Kinship, and the Polar Bear Dance (Part 2)

Clay Newcomb riding a mule with text "BEAR GREASE" and "PRESENTED BY TECOVAS"

Play Episode

59m

550 miles north of the Arctic Circle, survival demands a different way of seeing the world. In the second installment of our High Arctic Series, Clay Newcomb continues exploring traditional Inuit life, the remarkable people who have adapted to one of the harshest environments on earth, and the cultural differences that challenge many of our Western assumptions.

25-year-old Inuit hunter Devon Manik shares a story of chasing a polar bear across the sea ice with his team of sled dogs. What begins as an afternoon hunt turns into a marathon for survival.

Clay also continues the conversation with Arctic researcher and author Dr. Frank Tester to explore the history and worldview of the Inuit, from the importance of extended family and traditional naming practices to their relationship with animals, the land, and material possessions. Their perspective raises some interesting questions about our own relationship with the natural world, the things we accumulate, and the people around us.

This episode lays the groundwork for one of the most controversial chapters in modern Inuit history: the forced relocation of Inuit families to Canada’s High Arctic in 1953. That story is coming next.

Pre-Order Clay's new book "American Bear" at AmericanBearBook.com

Thank you to our sponsor, Tecovas.

If you have comments on the show, send us a note to beargrease@themeateater.com

Connect with Clay and MeatEater

Clay on Instagram

00:00:01 Speaker 1: You learn a lot of things that allow you to participate in and hopefully contribute to debates and discussions about things in your own culture, which are really important. And as far as I'm concerned, a culture that is consuming itself to death is a culture that really needs to take that seriously. 00:00:23 Speaker 2: In this second episode in our Inuit series, we're going to continue to learn about traditional Inuit life. and how they went from nomadic hunters to people living in permanent settlements. I'm interested in how their worldview is different from a typical Westerner's. We're going to dig into that, but we're also going to talk about polar bears and Inuit dogs, because we know that curiosity killed the cat, but it also fuels some good stories, which are often complicated. So remember, the big story of our series is about the forced Inuit relocation to the high Arctic in 1953, and specifically how they ended up in Resolute Bay, a place which the Inuit hadn't lived in 500 years. I went to Resolute Bay. We hit on this in episode 520, but we really won't talk about that on this episode. We're laying the foundation for understanding that controversial saga. even though I'm in the high Arctic, the ice is thin and treacherous. I'd say it's highly doubtful that you're going to want to miss this one. And hey, you can watch my trip to the Arctic on Meat Eaters Season 14, which is now available on all our channels. You can watch it on YouTube. It's going to be stretched out over several episodes. And lastly... My book that I have been working on for the last three years, American Bear, is finally available for pre-order now. And if you order before December 9th through this porch light link, which we're going to share, I'll send you a signed American Bear Christmas card that you can put under the tree because the book won't be mailed out until February 9th. And you can pre-order that at www.americanbearbook.com. I cannot thank you enough. And if you've ever done anything for me to support us here, you could do this by buying our book. Thank you so much. My name is Clay Newcomb, and this is the Bear Grease Podcast, where we'll explore things forgotten but relevant, search for insight in unlikely places, and where we'll tell the story of Americans who lived their lives close to the land. Brought to you by Tecova's Boots. I'm a cowboy boot man, and I've been wearing Tecova's for years. They're the most comfortable boot I've ever put on. Good boots for good times. We met Devin Manick on the last episode, and I want to start off with a story from him. He's 25 years old. He lives in one of the northernmost cities in the world, Resolute Bay, Nunavut, Canada. And he hunts polar bear using the traditional Inuit method of chasing bears down while using dog sleds. What I learned when I was here is that the line between life and death gets thinner the further north you get from the Arctic Circle. And Devin lives 550 miles north of it. I asked Devin if he'd ever been in any hairy situations on the ice. And he had. In this story, Devin is a teenager. 00:03:53 Speaker 3: All right, so I had just come home from a... I was, like, guiding some people out on the ice. We got back, and I had a little bit of time before the next, you know, people came up. 00:04:06 Speaker 1: So. 00:04:07 Speaker 3: I decided I'm going to go look for a bear with the dogs. But just not too far, just like for the day, you know. So I headed south to Griffith Island. I saw a few seals. I shot at them, but I missed. So I just kept moving on. And because I was only going for the day, I didn't pack much. I didn't take my park. It was pretty warm that day. 00:04:32 Speaker 2: What's pretty warm? 00:04:34 Speaker 3: It was like minus 18. Okay. Yeah. So I didn't need my parka, so it was pretty warm for me. Yeah, like, I didn't take any camping equipment, no sleeping bags, just a cushion, my skin where I sit on the dog sled, and what I had on my body, and a gun. Yeah, so we headed out, got behind the island, and I was like, all right, I should probably start heading back because we're a bit far now. But then I see this bear, and I was like, oh, it's a bear. I want this bear. I need to get it because I won't be able to go up for a while. So I started chasing it, and the dogs were tired at that point. I should have just cut it off right then, but I just kept going. And we chased that bear in circles. Like, we went down, back, next to the island, through the rubble ice. 00:05:30 Speaker 2: And you're on your sled, and the dogs are pulling the sled, and you're chasing this bear across the ice. 00:05:34 Speaker 1: Yep. 00:05:35 Speaker 3: I think we chased it for like three hours. We were out there for so long and it was starting to get dark. This is like April. So it wasn't fully dark. It was just like twilight. But we chased it and chased it and chased it. And finally the bear just gave up and it turned around and it waited for us to come in. 00:05:54 Speaker 2: A polar bear and a pack of Inuit dogs pulling a sled are roughly the same speed. Who outruns the other depends on the day and its many variables. like how fresh the dogs are or how close the chase starts to rough ice. Closer is good for bears and bad for sleds. Or the chase can simply come down to the mood of the bear. These are the physical variables, but consistent with the people who live in the boreal regions, Devon believes there's a spiritual component and it's the bear's choice if he's allowed to kill it. The traditional way of hunting is simple. You spot a bear on the sea ice, often over a mile away, and the hunter mushes the dogs towards it to chase it. The bear will usually spot the hunter once he's inside of a half a mile and the chase is on. One of two things will eventually happen. The bear will outrun the sled and vanish like a frigid mirage where the bear tires, stops, and turns to face the dog. The hunter then releases from the team's harness what he calls his bear-dogs. are the ones most interested in baying a bear. Devin says there's usually a few that are more aggressive than the others. And Inuit sled dogs are bred primarily as pulling dogs. And yes, they are a specific breed, formally known as Canadian Inuit dogs. They aren't Alaskan Huskies or Malamutes. They're genetically distinct, but they look similar. And from my personal interactions, they appear barely over the threshold of domestication. Their eyes aren't tame. They stare listlessly through a stranger as much wolf as dog. He instructed me not to pet them. But they aren't big, probably 50 pounds max, with long, wiry hair, white, black, and rust brown. They sleep curled in the snow as seemingly as comfortable as a man in a recliner. Many nights on the ice, I was awoken by their synchronous howling, like an acapella choir, 20 voices in perfect harmony. I couldn't have distinguished their song from a pack of wolves. When they did this, Devin would rustle from his sleeping bag, locate his rifle, and sit patiently in the dark, assuming a polar bear was near our camp. Daylight couldn't arrive fast enough. In 1920, it was believed that 20,000 Inuit dogs were in the Arctic, but in 2008, less than 500 purebred dogs remained. Devon has a pack of 20 plus. They're bred with the desire to pull against weight when they're in a collar. However, some of them like to bay a bear, but if they're too aggressive or catchy, they'll get killed. Aggression is the Achilles heel of any variety of bear dog. But if they're too passive, they can't catch one and make it stop. When the bear turns to fight, the Inuit call it when the dogs dance with the bear or the polar bear dance. They spin circles like a waltz. We're going to pick up this story as the dogs are dancing and things escalate quickly. 00:09:14 Speaker 3: I didn't even, like, let dogs loose. I just jumped off the sled, grabbed my gun, and as soon as it turned, I shot it, like, super quick. It was down. And I was, like, heavy breathing, like, holy cow, I've actually done this. I did it. We got the bear. Then I looked at the time. It was, like, 11 p.m. It was getting dark. I had to use my headlamp. 00:09:40 Speaker 2: How far are you from Resolute Bay? 00:09:42 Speaker 3: I was probably 30 kilometers. Okay. But when we chased the bear, we did like circles. So we probably did more because the dogs were exhausted. As soon as I killed the bear, the dogs laid down because they were tired. But I couldn't get home that that night because the dogs couldn't do it so and I didn't bring my parka I didn't bring a sleeping bag so I was in a pickle so I had to I only had I brought some hot water but midday I drank most of it so I had just a tiny bit left I think I drank the rest of that it was cold by the time we got the bear I butchered the bear Well, the dogs slept. I guess when I finished cutting up, they woke up and they wanted something to eat, so I gave them something to eat. And then I only had the tarp on my dog's side. I always bring a tarp to keep snow out of certain gear. So I put my bear fur that I use as a seat inside, and I cuddled in there, wrapped myself in the tarp, and I probably slept for like an hour. And that night the temperature dropped to like minus 28. So it felt cold. And when I... I think I slept for like an hour. And then I woke up super cold. And I couldn't get warm after that. Like I could not warm up at all. Everything I would try to run around. Jumping jacks. Nothing worked. So I just stayed up. But the dogs needed rest. So I let them rest until the morning. And that morning... All I had for breakfast was Tylenol. I was looking through my bin and I found some Tylenol. So I had the Tylenol. It's better than nothing, I guess. So I had that. I think I grabbed some snow in my mouth and thawed it out. And then drank the Tylenol. I tried calling for help with my in-reach. But they said they couldn't get to me last night. 00:11:41 Speaker 2: Who said they couldn't get you? 00:11:43 Speaker 3: My grandfather. 00:11:44 Speaker 2: He just was like, you're on your own? 00:11:46 Speaker 3: Yeah, so... The next day, I started going. And just as we were leaving, another bear was in our path. And it saw us and ran off. And it was a bigger bear than the one I got. I was like, oh, that would have been nice. But I just kept going. We were going pretty slow. The dogs were tired. And we had to pull the bear in tow. You know, the hide and meet on the dog sled. But we just kept going and going and going. And it felt forever. And the whole time, I was just freezing. It was like... Like inside of me was cold, you know, like my core. It didn't feel good. And I was so tired. I only slept like an hour after butchering a bear, chasing it all day. Yeah. But we just kept going. Eventually we got about halfway home. And I see my grandfather come up behind me on his Somerville. He's like, I've been looking for you all day. So he said he followed my tracks everywhere. But he followed my tracks where I chased the bear. Yeah. So he went all over the place and he went around me and I guess I just missed him. 00:12:53 Speaker 2: Oh. 00:12:53 Speaker 3: Then he took the bear meat and all that and I just kept going and we made it home. 00:13:01 Speaker 2: Having spent several days on the sea ice with Devin, let me tell you, if he says he was cold, it probably would have killed the average person. And I don't think I'm exaggerating. I find the stories of Devin's life, which are so normal to him, to be fascinating and bizarre. A teenager leaving his house for a casual afternoon polar bear hunt on a dog sled 15 miles out on sea ice. Things that can become normal for humans reveal the breadth of possibilities of our kind and how our full capacity is rarely realized. But enough about humans and dogs. I want to read an excerpt about polar bears. from the late Barry Lopez's book, Arctic Dreams. The farmer, the whalers who called him, for his very agricultural appearance as he stalks leisurely over the furrowed fields of ice. John Muir, on a visit to these same waters in 1899, said bears move as if the country had belonged to them always. The polar bear is a creature of arctic edges, He hunts the ice margins, the surface of the water, and the continental shore. The ice bear, he's called. His world forms beneath him in the days of shortening light and then falls away in the spring. He dives to the ocean floor for mussels and kelp and soundlessly breaks the water's glassy surface on his return to study a sleeping seal. Twenty miles from the shore, he treads water amid schooling fish, the sea bear. In winter... While the grizzly hibernates, the polar bear is out on the sea ice hunting. In summer, his tracks turn up hundreds of miles inland where he feasts on crowberries and blueberries. Until a few years ago, this resourceful hunter was in the genus by himself, Thalartos. Now he's back where he started, with the grizzly and black bear in the genus Ursus, where his genes, if not his behavior, say he belongs. End of quote. Male polar bears can be 12 feet tall and weigh 2,000 pounds. On average, they're larger than brown bears. However, the subspecies of Kodiak brown bears can weigh more than a polar bear. So the Kodiak would hold the title for largest bear in terms of weight. There was one that they recorded that was over 2,100 pounds. But the largest polar bears would be longer than a Kodiak. According to Lopez, polar bears get larger as you move from east to west. Their hair is translucent, absorbing solar energy and delivering it to their black skin like a fiber optic cable. Surprisingly, their fur loses 90% of its insulation power when wet, but their body is kept warm by their fat. According to Lopez, the infrared photography of the 1980s was unable to pick up polar bear's heat signature. because they just weren't losing heat. It's believed that polar bears are pretty new. Genetically, they diverged from brown bears less than 5,000 years ago. The Inuit of Greenland called the polar bear the Great Wanderer, and rightfully so. Once, a tag bear in Svalbard, Norway, showed up a year later 2,000 miles away in Greenland. It's hard to imagine, but these continents separated by oceans are part of the year connected by ice. Once a radio collared sow polar bear traveled 205 miles in two days. Once they found a polar bear at 6,600 feet in elevation on a mountain in Norway. Among Inuit, it's widely believed that polar bears are left-handed. And Lopez writes that if one must leap in desperation from a charging bear, it should always be to the bear's right. I thought about this while I was on the ice with Devin when his dogs howled. A polar bear's nose is the only thing on its body that isn't white. Some believe it's a built-in seal decoy and that a basking seal might believe the bear's black nose is another seal a long ways off as the bear approaches. A polar bear hunts like a big cat. A healthy polar bear will eat the blubber of a seal and leave most of the meat, so often arctic foxes pair up with the bear to eat what he leaves. I myself saw polar bear tracks and fox tracks traveling like a pair of friends. Polar bears also catch belugas, narwhals, and walrus, all giant animals far bigger than a bear. A polar bear can swim like a seal, diving down to 45 feet, holding their breath for over three minutes. Did you know that polar bear liver is toxic, having concentrations of vitamin A so strong that it will kill a man or dog? Devin buries the liver so his dogs won't eat it. Lopez wrote, and this is a quote, that... In 1874, two American observers saw 250 to 300 bears together on St. Matthew Island in Bering Sea, placidly grazing and rooting about like hogs. In 1980, scientists counted 56 of them at Bowhead Well Carcass in the Svalbard Coast. This is still in the quote, but Larson says scientists don't have an explanation for how bears get wind of these things. Odor likely plays a role, but bears come from all directions and some from very far away. They just get to a place where something is happening, Larson says, and they get there quickly. This kind of makes you think they have some kind of sense that we can't pick up on. Things that we can't explain by physics that deliver information we often call supernatural. The Inuit call the bear Tornarsik, which means the one who gives power. In my upcoming book, American Bear, about the black bear, you'll see how the indigenous people across the boreal regions viewed the bear as a powerful non-human person controlling the outcomes of human lives based upon how they treated the bear in the hunt. But that is another story. But one thing's for sure, the Inuit love to hunt polar bear, but it's risky business. Lopez wrote this, an Arctic traveler, once asked an Eskimo man about happiness, about exhilaration, and he answered, to come across a fresh set of bear tracks and be ahead of all the other sledges. End of quote. That's one of the coolest descriptions of happiness that I've heard. Who are these people? Who would say that? I think it's now time to transition to part two of this episode and ask Devin a question, not about polar bears or Inuit sled dogs, but about the Inuit themselves. How would you describe the Inuit people? 00:20:21 Speaker 3: Oh, very, very strong, very resilient, very smart. Like they could build a watercraft to hunt a walrus or narwhal from driftwood and skins with their two hands, you know? Like, very little resources, but they could make so much amazing stuff to survive out here. And, like, you came here in March. It's a pretty good time because it's bright. 00:20:45 Speaker 2: Mm-hmm. 00:20:45 Speaker 3: But imagine coming out here for, like, a whole year and, like, having none of this. Like, even for me. Like, I rely on, you know, kerosene and naphtha for heating. But they only had oil lamps and spears and bow and arrow. So they had to make all of it by themselves. Mm-hmm. From the land. 00:21:04 Speaker 2: Mm-hmm. 00:21:05 Speaker 3: Very strong very resilient and it makes me proud of my people I look up to my ancestors like the guy that I named my son after very amazing yeah. 00:21:21 Speaker 2: It seems like it's important to you to be a to tell the story of your people I just feel like. 00:21:29 Speaker 3: I should just keep it alive so it's not lost it's part of our identity You know, if we're just like everybody else, then we're just like everybody else. But we have something up here and a history and a culture that I don't want to die. And me, you know, me dog sledding and all that, it's helping keeping it alive. Me here talking on the podcast about it, it's keeping it alive. So I guess, yeah, I have a little, I have a responsibility. 00:22:04 Speaker 2: I'm interested in learning about Inuit culture in part by using a mechanism of comparison, by contrasting it with what I'm familiar with. And I'd like to start this section about the Inuit by reading an excerpt from the book The Arctic Grail by Pierre Burton. These are the first words of his 600-page book about the quest for the Northwest Passage. Stay with me. 00:22:31 Speaker 3: He writes.... 00:22:33 Speaker 2: In the published memoirs of that stubborn and often maddening Arctic explorer, Sir John Ross, there is a remarkable illustration of an encounter that took place on August 10, 1818, between two British naval officers and a band of Greenland Eskimos. So he's saying there's a painting of this thing. The most striking thing about this drawing is the contrast of cultures it depicts. The Eskimos are dressed as one might expect in jackets, trousers, and boots made of fur and seal skin, perfectly adapted for the harsh climate of Ultima Thule. These two men who greet them are attired exactly as they would be had they been envoys to some palm-fringed island in the South Pacific or off the coast of Africa. There they stand, resplendent in cocked hats, tailcoats, and white gloves, swords dangling from their waists. The points of their buckled shoes that once trod the parquet floors of Mayfair sinking into the soft snow. Costumed actors in a savage land. Behind them, against a magnificent backdrop of chiseled mountains, their two ships floated anchor. Square-rigged vessels of the kind that defeated the French at Traofagar, but will prove hopelessly unfit for Arctic channels. The seamen aboard are shivering in regulation wool and broadcloth since no exploring nation has yet to recognize the need for special Arctic clothing. Officers and natives are equally startled by the unexpected encounter. The two people view the world in ways as different as their appearance. Almost a century will pass before either recognizes the need to understand or learn from the other. The British officers have until now only met one Eskimo, the anglicized interpreter John Chasseuse, whom they call Sackhouse. The Eskimos here on the rim of Melville Bay on the western shore of Greenland have never before seen a white man. To the naval officers who stand peering at these strange squat creatures muffed in furs, the moon itself could scarcely seem more remote than this bleak treeless shore. To the Eskimos, their astonishing visitors must be celestial beings. In a dialect that Sackhouse can hardly understand, they ask, where do you come from, the sun or the moon? End of quote. With the exercise of great rationality, these Inuit men knew only two locations other than the earth, the sun and the moon that they could see. that these Englishmen must be from, because clearly they couldn't be from planet Earth. The striking painting of this encounter by John Sashuz is pretty wild, this interpreter. I just think that story is incredible. But you'll remember Dr. Frank J. Tester from the last episode. He's an expert on the high Arctic, an author, a professor, a boat builder, a poet. He lives in British Columbia, Canada. and spent several years in the High Arctic. He's a jack of all trades. And I asked him to tell me about the Inuit. We've covered a little bit of this deep Inuit history that he's going to start with, because he's going to go way back. But it's going to lead us into some completely new information. 00:26:03 Speaker 1: There's a lot of controversy about where they came from. Although, more recently, the notion that they perhaps had origins in Mongolia has received some attention and a fair bit of acceptance. Inuit have been there since the end of the Ice Age, since they were able to cross the, in that case, the Bering Strait. 00:26:27 Speaker 2: That would be roughly 10,000 years, could we say? 00:26:31 Speaker 1: Yeah, we're talking thousands of years ago. And Inuit are very family-oriented, and by that I mean extended family. Extended families are really important. Inuit, of course, it makes sense because Inuit survived by organizing themselves into camps and family-based camps. So you might have anywhere from 15 to 45 people perhaps living together in a camp, and they'd all be related in some way or another, with a camp boss, which would be someone who was seen to be the most knowledgeable person about all of the things that are necessary in order to survive in that kind of environment, which means somebody who's wise with regard to weather, somebody who's knowledgeable about when to hunt where and how, may also, but not necessarily, be very skilled at making the tools that were required for hunting before the introduction of rifles and Western steel products. which came with the whalers starting in the 1830s along the east coast of Baffin Island. So family and family life is really important. I mean, Inuit are the best ones to talk about their own history and culture, but all I can say is things that I've observed. And one of the things I've observed is related to Inuit youth who may come into southern Canada to go to school. They have a hard time. You know, they miss their families. They miss the support of their families. And they often, you know, don't last. They, you know, after a year or even less of experiencing time spent in a southern university or college, they go home. And they go home for what I would call family reasons. And I quite respect them for that. Family ties and relationships are everything. And that's Reflected in traditional naming practices. My friend Zacharias Kunak, his film, which won first prize at Cannes in 2002, Atanar Jowat, or Fast Runner, there's a character in there who constantly is referring to her daughter as my little mother. And that's because her daughter is named after her mother. And this was a practice where often a child would be named after the person who had most recently died in the extended family network. In this case, it happens to be her mother, which, and that may not be uncommon because even in our own culture, sometimes, you know, children receive the name of a deceased ancestor. But the naming is very, very important. And so what happens is there's a behavioral thing that goes with it. She treats her daughter with the same kind of respect that she would afford her mother. So naming is very important. And some people historically did not have surnames. They just had a name. It wasn't until 1969 when the government launched something called Project Naming that Inuit were forced to to choose a surname or a family name. And some Inuit had more than one name. Some Inuit were known by five or six different names, but only one name. They were called this, or somebody else might call them that, but they didn't have a family name per se. So the project naming, I think, caused a lot of problems and a lot of grief because it had huge implications for culture, consequently. And that's just one of many things, ways in which Canadian or Euro-Canadian culture has impacted upon Inuit culture in what I think are fairly negative ways. So these large family-based camps were important because people had to work together. If you're hunting caribou, for example, on the tundra with a bow and arrow, You have to be fairly close, as you probably know. You know, it's not the same as working with a rifle. But, you know, it's awfully hard to get close to a caribou when you're out on the tundra and, you know, there's nothing to hide behind. You know, you can, the caribou will... So having other people who might, you know, chase the caribou or move the caribou in the direction where the hunter is hidden was extremely important to a successful hunt. Caribou historically were also taken at crossings in rivers and streams where They were easily harpooned from a kayak. But then again, you know, dragging the carcass of an animal up onto land, and this would be especially true of narwhal or whales, you can't do this by yourself. You have to work together. So social relations in these camps were extremely important. And the thing that I've noticed, and this is just my own take as a Kavlunat looking in from outside, is that There are two things that are true for many Inuit at the same time. They're incredibly collectively oriented. They're very community oriented. Interpersonal relations get a lot of attention. And they're very, very important. But they also have a lot of autonomy at the same time. 00:32:13 Speaker 2: What I'm hearing Frank say is that the nature of how these people made a living, essentially their economics... mandated a unique reliance upon each other for literal survival more than the average modern person. And this affected the nature of their relationships. And here's the question. Could human relationships in hunter-gatherer societies and modern Western societies be different? I'm asking myself, are there options for how a human views relationships that are almost out of our control? And many say yes. I want to read from Frank's book, Tamarnit, which means mistakes in Inuktitut, about a difference between modern Western society and the Inuit. And it has to do with how we view material objects. He starts by naming an anthropologist. So here we go. Marshall Salins has characterized at a very abstract level, a fundamental difference between hunting societies and modern society's as embodied in forms of thought, what he calls the locus of symbolic production. So we've kind of got to stop right here to capture this odd phrase, the locus of symbolic production. And just stay with me because we've got to define this anthropological term, which is hard for me to understand. It's kind of fussy and pretentious, but it's powerful. The locus of symbolic production of a culture is the primary place institution or social space where meaning and cultural values and shared symbols are created and legitimized so it's a place where a culture puts their most value and now tester will tell us where this locus of symbolic production is for the Inuit and he writes among hunting peoples kinship relations the bonds between people are the locus of symbolic production let me read that again Among hunting peoples, kinship relations, the bonds between people, are the locus of symbolic production. Basically, he's saying that these people relied on each other in such practical ways that they built different kinds of relationship than we see in most Western societies. Perhaps it could be argued, but the locus of production in Western society is a focus on individual achievement, accomplishment, and the acquisition of material objects. a.k.a. acquisition of money. He and or I are suggesting that people in Western societies don't love their families. This is a common trait of Homo sapiens. But he is saying that an extreme focus on externals takes away focus from relationships and changes it. Is there variance in how people love and care for one another? Is there a hierarchy in which relationships are held inside the human heart? I say yes. This is going to make more sense when I read something else that Frank wrote in his book about humans' fascination or lack of fascination with material objects. So this book was published in the early 90s. So here's a quote. In the context of this book, one of these differences is particularly worth closer examination. How do we look at objects? How do we see things around us? For a gatherer or hunter, objects may often be viewed with suspicion. Any object found will have to be carried. Therefore, it is seen first in terms of weight. For people from agricultural or settled society, objects are seen first in terms of desire. Any object found may have a value, and after all, even if it isn't worth anything, why not take it since there's a place for you to put it? Hunting peoples do not tend to accumulate material goods. Saving them for the long term has little meaning. Industrial society is based on logic of capital accumulation served by processes of totalization. Accumulation of material objects is so deeply rooted as an individual motivation in Western thought that it has been constructed as an aspect of human nature. Yeah, I can't believe I said all that, but I guess I'm guilty. 00:36:45 Speaker 1: Yes. Yeah, material objects in our culture have a taken-for-granted significance that, you know, as a result of taking it for granted, you know, I would say we're missing out on some things. We're missing out on some things that are really important to having a good life. And that's, you know, a particular kind of relationship with other people. When we become owned by our objects, we become limited in all kinds of different ways. 00:37:17 Speaker 2: Frank wrote that the accumulation of material objects is so deeply rooted as an individual motivation in Western thought that it has been constructed as an aspect of human nature. What he's saying is that it's not, and that our desire for more stuff is an artifact of the affluence of our times, not simply a result of being a human. Can you imagine a human that wasn't interested in gathering stuff up to keep? Tester went on to say, the change from nomadic to settled existence has extraordinary and unforeseen consequences, not least on our way of seeing, our way of looking at objects. We also just heard a big nerdy anthropological term called totalization, which I had no idea what it meant, but it basically means that a government needs people to all be the same. For a nation to exist, they couldn't have people out there living a completely different lifestyle with a different economy and a different worldview. Totalization means to unify the citizens into the same economy. Western society historically hasn't handled nomadic hunters well enough and have always sought to attach them to permanent settlements. Tester said that settlement was one of the tools of the logic of totalization, that in the material establishment of settlement, kinship bonds were weakened. Basically, the quote's done here, basically the glue of their culture was manipulated in such a way that it was crushed. This is a similar story to the American Indians. And now, Frank is going to slap us right between the eyes with some uncomfortable stuff. Be ready. 00:39:05 Speaker 1: This is a big problem in Western European cultures. It's how we're doing ourselves in. I mean, people talk about climate change as being a matter of carbon dioxide going into the atmosphere. And they're not wrong. But, you know, I see the climate crisis or the climate emergency that we're now facing as being very much related to how we relate to objects. We are consuming ourselves to death. We are acquiring more and more and more. I mean, if you look at what the average person, and I'm guilty of this to some extent myself, although I think about it and try to do something about it, but nevertheless it's darn difficult. I live in my culture. We all do. So I'm not saying this to try and make people feel bad, but I do recognize that everything that we own has to be made, and everything that we make requires energy and materials. And all of that energy and materials has got byproducts, which is what we're looking at when we look up at a hot, sunny day where the sky is absolutely blazing and we're sweating to death. Our lifestyle, our values... are very much related to the climate environment emergency. This is a cultural crisis. It is not just a crisis of too much carbon dioxide and let's all go out and buy an electric vehicle or let's all get wind generators and solar panels. I raise serious questions, and much of it is inspired by my experience with Inuit, whom I greatly respect. There is not a technical solution to this problem. This is a cultural problem that's more fundamental than we realize. We are basically taking from nature at a rate faster than nature can replenish. You can't do this forever. And we are getting close to the line if we're not already over it. 00:41:08 Speaker 2: What Frank is saying hits hard and is flat out uncomfortable and is politically uncouth to talk about in some circles. But it's interesting to me that when we started talking to people from the high Arctic, that the climate crisis or whatever our political masters permit us to call this thing came up. It's a bummer that this is such a political topic because it muzzles many people, including myself to some degree. But it's now to the point that no one can deny the climate is rapidly changing. My friend Mark Kenyon has a new book coming out called Before They're Gone that does a good job of painting a picture of where we're at. You should check that out. It's coming out in January. But here's Frank. 00:41:54 Speaker 1: So this is why I myself enjoy spending time in other cultures, you know, and I'm, as I said to you earlier, I see myself as quite privileged, you know, I've spent time, a lot of time in Mozambique, I've spent time in Tanzania, I lived in the South Pacific in Vanuatu for a while, I've worked in Nicaragua, I lived in New Zealand and got in touch with Maori culture, I've taught in China briefly, you know, I mean, talk about privilege, but when you do this, when you spend time in other cultures, you learn a lot of things that allow you to participate in and hopefully contribute to debates and discussions about things in your own culture, which are really important. And as far as I'm concerned, a culture that is consuming itself to death is a culture that really needs to take that seriously. 00:42:50 Speaker 2: I'd say old Frank has a point. We live in our culture and are permitted to and should enjoy it and love it. But seeing into the lives of others is powerful for self-reflection. One of the hardest parts of human existence is seeing life through the eyes of someone else. In many ways, I would say that this was a core teaching of a young Jewish carpenter who changed the planet by this idea of loving your neighbor as yourself. This has a literal local application, as in love the hillbilly down the street with his barking, slick tree and walker dogs. But the principle is scalable and can expand out to the macro. And according to Little Tree in the book, The Education of Little Tree by the con man Asa Carter, love is simply understanding someone. So understanding the Inuit helps me understand humans and helps me identify strengths and and the weaknesses inside of myself. I could get lost in some kind of nerd-out time portal thinking about nomadic hunter-gatherer tribes, and it bugs my wife, and I'll do my best to reel it in here, but forgive me, there is more. The characteristics of these societies are common amongst hunter-gatherer tribes in general. 00:44:11 Speaker 1: Yes. 00:44:12 Speaker 2: It's like if you take a human being and drop them into... an environment where they have to hunt, gather, be nomadic, and you leave them there for a thousand years, it's almost like you're guaranteed that you're going to get, for that to work, you're going to come out of it with this set of values. 00:44:32 Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah. 00:44:34 Speaker 2: Because if you were to go to some of the indigenous people anywhere in the world, I just find that interesting, that we're that programmed to... fit to our environment, but also you start to see some of the, as you assess these things, you see the strengths and weaknesses of our species. 00:44:54 Speaker 1: Yeah, absolutely. And the idea that things were looked upon with a certain amount of suspicion for nomadic and semi-nomadic people when you have to carry everything from one location to the next. You want to think what it is that you really have to take and is well worth taking and what you can do without. So objects become a matter of, hmm, I don't know. Whereas, you know, we just call up a moving van and, you know, we just dump everything into it and take it to a new location where we acquire even more stuff. And of course, this is changing. I mean, that's what, you know, that's what the modern world is about. I mean, I can go back and read Franz Boas' description of how, you know, we're living in the 1880s, for example, on Baffin Island and And, you know, it's only 100 years, well, 100 and a bit years ago. And a different world in terms of values and the way in which people lived, obviously not, you know, overwhelmed with Canadian and Euro-Canadian materialism. And, of course, it's changing because, you know, Inuit are now living in communities. They drive cars. They have trucks. They have, you know, why shouldn't they? I mean, they're participating in Canadian culture. You know, it's something that they have to do and want to do, and there's no doubt about it. Inuit life historically, despite, you know, these values, which I see as being quite virtuous, there's no pretending that Inuit life wasn't hard. And, you know, the conditions under which they lived and the things that they had to do in order to survive were, like, really, really demanding. There was one point, I can't remember what years it covers now, Early 40s when tuberculosis, for example, was taking a hell of a toll on Inuit and it was introduced by Scottish whalers probably in the 1830s and nothing was done about it until just before and then immediately after the Second World War. The average lifespan, the average Inuit lifespan was 19 years. 00:47:06 Speaker 2: I don't want to over-romanticize this culture. I like stuff. I like living in the temperate climates. I like having a nice house and a decent truck. But I think this time period with what Frank just told us about the Inuit having a 19-year lifespan puts this thing into perspective of how hard their lives were at times. And obviously, today, lifespans are much higher. But to get back to the practical ways the Inuit lived, Their specialization to the land is unique. Housing made of blocks of snow, some elaborately connected by tunnels. Sleds made without nails or screws, but lashed together by animal skin ropes. Today, they still don't use nails because the sleds have to flex. And the utilization of dogs, the only animal they would ever domesticate. These people had to be dialed. When I was there, and the more I've learned about the Inuits, there's never been a people more adapted to a landscape that were any more in tune with it. 00:48:18 Speaker 1: Oh, yeah. 00:48:19 Speaker 2: And their ability to survive, because the margin in climates that extreme between life and death is so small. Yeah. There is no wiggle room. 00:48:29 Speaker 1: Yeah. 00:48:29 Speaker 2: It's like life has to be incredibly precise. 00:48:33 Speaker 3: Yeah. 00:48:33 Speaker 2: You can't get too far out of the boundaries. And so, you know, after thousands of years, they just have... all these tools dialed, they have the way of life dialed, they have relationships dialed, they have. 00:48:45 Speaker 1: Reading the weather down, you know, from the time they were young kids. I mean, I was told by elders that when we were kids, we had to get up in the morning, put our boots on, and go outside and look up at the sky and read the sky and go back and tell our elders what the weather was going to be like for the day. Mm-hmm. And reading the weather was really important. In fact, reading the weather was important to survival. Because if there was a storm coming in and you, you know, went out on the land and you were... 50 kilometers away from the camp and you got hit with a blast of weather you were finished so you know reading reading the weather and respecting the weather and knowing when it was a good time to go hunting and when it was uh not and knowing where to go and what the weather was going to be like was everything. 00:49:44 Speaker 2: It seems like a given, but these people have psychological strength in their ability to hunker down for bad weather. While in the Arctic, I noticed a unique patience that would be frustrating to many people. And patience is a relevant word in the Arctic. In Inuktitut, they use a word for patience like we have, but they have a second and different word that means extreme patience, like what would be needed when waiting for a migrating herd of caribou or waiting at a seal's breathing hole. Barry Lopez taught us this. In milder climates, technology can overcome weather, but not here, not even now. Talking about their connection to the natural world through being able to understand weather reminded me of something that I've read about in Arctic Dreams where They were talking about navigation of land. There's a section where they had asked an Inuit to draw out a map of a peninsula that had all the inlets. And it was incredibly, you know, just circuitous, serrated. I mean, just this map that he drew by memory of all the inlets, the rivers. And he draws this map. And this was like in the 1800s. And then they have an actual modern map of this huge expanse of land. I want to say it was like hundreds of miles that this guy had mapped by memory. And you see the modern map and what this guy drew by just memory. And they were incredibly accurate. There was a whole big section about how these people related to the land. And he also noted that the people made land features when they drew it on maps bigger based upon importance. And so if there was a particular place that was good hunting, an inlet, they might draw it bigger than it actually was. Basically, they were trying to say this place is important. So in real life, it was much smaller. But it was interesting. 00:52:02 Speaker 1: Western Europeans used to do exactly the same. If you look at medieval maps of Europe, some places are more prominent on the map than others, and they're out of proportion to what was true in terms of space or geographical area. That's exactly the way in which we also used to draw maps. It sends a message to a map as information, and it's very useful to have... drawn not in a cold sort of detached objective way as if we had no relationship to the space. Maps historically were always made to communicate with the person viewing them what was important. 00:52:46 Speaker 2: Barry Lopez talked a lot about how these Europeans were communicating with the Inuit. He made note of how when he would ask them or when the Europeans would ask a question about distance. He would say, how far is it from here to here? In the Inuit, they would describe it in days travel. Their description of distance was so different than obviously people coming from Europe that were measuring distances. 00:53:18 Speaker 1: Yeah, and even days travel is not quite you know, accurate because as we talked about earlier, when daylight and nighttime are, depending on the time of year, entirely different, you know, what constitutes a day? I mean, we have watches, but that's a different thing altogether. It's kind of like, well, depending on the weather and depending if it's October and if the weather's good, you can get there in about three sleeps, you know, or, you know, if you're young and, you know, you just try really hard Maybe one sleep will get you there. The distance depended on who you were, not on some objective measurement. 00:54:00 Speaker 2: The absence of objective measurements is interesting. The late Barry Lopez wrote about an interesting scenario that has to do with landscapes. He wrote that Stephenson, this explorer, who was once asked by an Eskimo to whom he was showing a pair of binoculars for the first time, whether he could see into tomorrow with them. Stephenson took the question literally and was amused. What the Inuk probably meant was, are those things powerful enough to see something that we will not reach for another day, like migrating caribou, or a part of the landscape suitable for a campsite, which you yourself will not reach for another day. End of quote. As we explore the differences in Inuit and Western cultures, I want to read more from Lopez's book, and it's about people and animals. A fundamental difference between our culture and Eskimo culture, which can be felt even today in certain situations, is that we have irrevocably separated ourselves from the world that animals occupy. We have turned all animals and elements of the natural world into objects. We manipulate them to serve the complicated ends of our destiny. Eskimos do not grasp this separation easily and have difficulty imagining themselves entirely removed from the world of animals. For many of them, to make this separation is analogous to cutting oneself off from light or water. It is hard to imagine how to do it. A second difference is that because we have objectified animals we're able to treat them impersonally. This means not only the animals that live around us, but animals that live in distant lands. For Eskimos, most relationships with animals are local and personal. The animals one encounters are part of one's community and one has obligations to them. The most confusing aspect of Western culture for Eskimos to grasp is our depersonalization of relationships with the human and animal members of our communities. And it is compounded rather than simplified by their attempting to learn how to objectify animals. Eskimos do not maintain this intimacy with nature without paying a certain price. When I've thought about the ways in which they differ from people in our own culture, I've realized that they are more afraid than we are. On a day-to-day basis, they have more fear. Not of being dumped into cold water from an UMAC, not a debilitating fear. They are afraid because they accept fully what is violent and tragic in nature. It is a fear tied to their knowledge that sudden, cataclysmic events are as much a part of life, of really living, as are the moments when one pauses to look at something beautiful. The central Eskimo shaman named Ahu, queried by Nudd Rasmussen about Eskimo belief, answered, We do not believe, we fear. End of quote. I am not an animist, nor do I believe that animal life is as valuable as human life. But I do believe the pendulum of a Westerner's worldview might move some if they thought about this. The biblical story in Genesis is often seen as the culprit of Westerner's separation of animals into something other. However, I think it's possible that we've missed a key principle. For the first job given by God to man was to name and care for animals. I think that's pretty unique. And as we know, your mission, your work, what you do is part of our functional identity. And it seems to me that God, in part, defined humanity in the context of animals. And it seems clear and rational that we do have authority over them, just like he said we did. But I think there's a biblical basis for a respect for for animals that our culture hasn't realized in some time I don't think this means that we should worship animals or assume their equal and spiritual value but I do think it means something different than the average westerner displays in their connection to animals I think Devin understands something about polar bears that a lot of people don't but until the next episode we're just going to have to leave it right here And next time, I pretty much pinky promise, pretty much, that we are going to get into the controversy of the Inuit relocation of 1953. A story that you have not heard and is unreal that we don't know about because of how wild it is. And I just can't thank you all enough for listening. to Bear Grease. If you have enjoyed this, if you think it's fascinating like I do, please share it with a friend. Just text this episode to somebody. And hey, don't forget to watch the episodes of Meat Eater on our YouTube channel and all the other channels. Oh man, I got a lot of stuff for y'all to do. I'm so sorry, but this is a lot of work. Maybe you've enjoyed it. Buy my book, American Bear. Pre-order it. Thank you all so much. Really appreciate it. And keep the wild places wild, because that's where the Bears live.

Presented By

Featured Gear

Brown hunting bib overalls with chest zip pocket, adjustable straps, 'BEAR GREASE' patch
Save this product
First Lite
$250.00
Shop Now
Black trucker hat with mesh back and patch showing bear silhouette, sun, and text BEAR GREASE
Save this product
MeatEater Store
$35.00
Shop Now
Black knit beanie with rectangular patch of trees, bear, sun and text 'BEAR GREASE'
Save this product
MeatEater Store
$35.00
Shop Now
MeatEater gray T-shirt with mountain print, hunter silhouette and text THE FIRST FAR WEST; THE CUMBERLAND GAP
Save this product
Shop Now

While you're listening

The comments section requires Functionality cookies. Please enable Functionality cookies in Cookie Settings to view this content.

Save this episode